开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

倩倩加油鸭 · 2022年04月05日

老师您好，没明白这里statement2，看别的解答意思就是想说cash flow matching strategy can provide better immunization effects for non-parallel yield shifts.但是一定就能消除非平行移动的影响吗？☺️

  1. CFA III
  2. Fixed Income

NO.PZ2018120301000025

问题如下：

Leah informs Molly that DFC has a single $500 million liability due in nine years, and she wants SD&R to construct a bond portfolio that earns a rate of return sufficient to pay off the obligation. Leah expresses concern about the risks associated with an immunization strategy for this obligation. In response, Molly makes the following statements about liability-driven investing:

  • Statement 1: Although the amount and date of SD&R’s liability is known with certainty, measurement errors associated with key parameters relative to interest rate changes may adversely affect the bond portfolios.
  • Statement 2: A cash flow matching strategy will mitigate the risk from non-parallel shifts in the yield curve.
Which of Molly’s statements about liability-driven investing is (are) correct?

选项：

A.

Statement 1 only.

B.

Statement 2 only.

C.

Both Statement 1 and Statement 2.

解释：

Correct Answer: C

C is correct. Molly is correct that measurement error can arise even in immunization strategies for Type 1 cash flows, which have set amounts and set dates. Also, a parallel shift in yield curves is a sufficient but not a necessary condition to achieve the desired outcome. Non-parallel shifts as well as twists in the yield curve can change the cash flow yield on the immunizing portfolio; however, minimizing the dispersion of cash flows in the asset portfolio mitigates this risk. As a result, both statements are correct.

老师您好，没明白这里statement2，看别的解答意思就是想说cash flow matching strategy can provide better immunization effects for non-parallel yield shifts.但是一定就能消除非平行移动的影响吗？谢谢

添加评论
1 个答案
已采纳答案

发亮_品职助教 · 2022年04月06日

嗨，爱思考的PZer你好：


老师您好，没明白这里statement2，看别的解答意思就是想说cash flow matching strategy can provide better immunization effects for non-parallel yield shifts.但是一定就能消除非平行移动的影响吗？


一定可以消除利率的影响，实际上是利率的改变不会影响到Cash flow matching的匹配效果。


Cash flow matching的原理就是：

我们先分析负债现金流发生的日期与金额，这是我们需要满足的现金流流出。然后我们购买合适的债券组合，经过计算与设计，让债券的Coupon与本金现金流流入正正好等于负债的现金流流出，且Coupon以及本金现金流的发生日期也正正好等于负债现金流发生的日期。就是设计好资产现金流，让资产现金流严丝合缝地与负债现金流对上。


注意到，收到债券Coupon与本金的日期正正好是负债的到期日，所以Coupon现金流就发生在负债到期时，这样就不存在Coupon reinvestment risk。这样无论利率如何改变，都不影响Coupon现金流归还负债。

同时，又由于归还负债现金流还包含债券本金的自然到期，这是债券的自然到期，债券到期拿到的一定是本金面值，不存在Price risk。所以无论利率如何改变，也都不会影响本金现金流。


于是，设计好的Coupon现金流与本金现金流，都不受利率改变的影响，归还的金额也是我们提前计算好的，这样归还负债的现金流也就不受利率的影响了。这就导致Cash flow matching这种方法，可以消除利率的影响。


这就是这句结论：利率改变（Parallel shift也好，Non-parallel shift也好，都无所谓），都不影响Cash flow matching来偿还负债。


和Cash flow matching相对应的是Duration-matching。Duration-matching我们不管负债的现金流，我们匹配的原理是保证资产的收益不受利率的影响。

如何保证债券资产的收益不受利率的影响呢？

实际上是让利率改变时，债券的Coupon reinvestment risk与债券价格的Price risk相互抵消，即，利率改变对债券收益的影响途径就是Coupon reinvestment risk与Price risk，现在这两个风险抵消掉了，那么就意味着，利率改变不会影响到债券的投资收益，那么债券可以实现预期的增值，负债到期时，资产可以顺利实现增值偿还负债。

但要让Coupon reinvestment risk与Price risk相互抵消有一个前提，就是：只有利率的平行移动才能一定保证price risk与Coupon reinvestment risk完全抵消。

当发生非平行移动时，两个风险有可能会出现无法抵消的情况，如果这两个风险无法抵消，就会导致Duration-matching失效。

所以发生non-parallel shift时，Duration-matching相比就没那么保险了，于是Cash flow matching有更好的immunization效果。

----------------------------------------------
加油吧，让我们一起遇见更好的自己！

daiwin18 · 2022年10月31日

这位助教解析得非常到位！

  • 1

    回答

  • 3

    关注

  • 605

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2018120301000025 问题如下 Leahinforms Molly thC ha single $500 million liability e in nineyears, anshe wants SR to construa bonportfolio thearns a rateof return sufficient to poff the obligation. Leexpresses concern aboutthe risks associatewith immunization strategy for this obligation. Inresponse, Molly makes the following statements about liability-iveninvesting:Statement 1: Although the amount ante of SR’s liability is known with certainty, measurement errors associatewith key parameters relative to interest rate changes maersely affethe bonportfolios.Statement 2: A cash flow matching strategy will mitigate the risk from non-parallel shifts in the yielcurve. Whichof Molly’s statements about liability-iven investing is (are) correct? A.Statement 1 only. B.Statement 2 only. C.Both Statement 1 anStatement 2. CorreAnswer: is correct. Molly is correthmeasurement error carise even in immunization strategies for Type 1 cash flows, whihave set amounts anset tes. Also, a parallel shift in yielcurves is a sufficient but not a necessary contion to achieve the sireoutcome. Non-parallel shifts well twists in the yielcurve cchange the cash flow yielon the immunizing portfolio; however, minimizing the spersion of cash flows in the asset portfolio mitigates this risk. a result, both statements are correct. 然后一般在计算资产的Macaulration时，是对组合内各成份债券的Macaulration进行了简单的加权平均。这种加权平均算出来的数据，并不准确。因为会产生衡量误差（Measurement errors），而该指标又是匹配时需要满足的条件，所以这个误差会影响到匹配的效果。-------上面摘自最新那个问题回答。我的问题是这种计算属于measurement error还是mol risk/error。还是都属于？或者说measurement error和mol risk/error是否有被包含的关系呢？

2024-06-13 22:04 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018120301000025 问题如下 Leahinforms Molly thC ha single $500 million liability e in nineyears, anshe wants SR to construa bonportfolio thearns a rateof return sufficient to poff the obligation. Leexpresses concern aboutthe risks associatewith immunization strategy for this obligation. Inresponse, Molly makes the following statements about liability-iveninvesting:Statement 1: Although the amount ante of SR’s liability is known with certainty, measurement errors associatewith key parameters relative to interest rate changes maersely affethe bonportfolios.Statement 2: A cash flow matching strategy will mitigate the risk from non-parallel shifts in the yielcurve. Whichof Molly’s statements about liability-iven investing is (are) correct? A.Statement 1 only. B.Statement 2 only. C.Both Statement 1 anStatement 2. CorreAnswer: is correct. Molly is correthmeasurement error carise even in immunization strategies for Type 1 cash flows, whihave set amounts anset tes. Also, a parallel shift in yielcurves is a sufficient but not a necessary contion to achieve the sireoutcome. Non-parallel shifts well twists in the yielcurve cchange the cash flow yielon the immunizing portfolio; however, minimizing the spersion of cash flows in the asset portfolio mitigates this risk. a result, both statements are correct. 第一个statement哪里提到是ration matching呢能不能翻译一下这个statement。

2024-03-23 13:09 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018120301000025问题如下 Leahinforms Molly thC ha single $500 million liability e in nineyears, anshe wants SR to construa bonportfolio thearns a rateof return sufficient to poff the obligation. Leexpresses concern aboutthe risks associatewith immunization strategy for this obligation. Inresponse, Molly makes the following statements about liability-iveninvesting:Statement 1: Although the amount ante of SR’s liability is known with certainty, measurement errors associatewith key parameters relative to interest rate changes maersely affethe bonportfolios.Statement 2: A cash flow matching strategy will mitigate the risk from non-parallel shifts in the yielcurve. Whichof Molly’s statements about liability-iven investing is (are) correct? A.Statement 1 only.B.Statement 2 only.C.Both Statement 1 anStatement 2. CorreAnswer: is correct. Molly is correthmeasurement error carise even in immunization strategies for Type 1 cash flows, whihave set amounts anset tes. Also, a parallel shift in yielcurves is a sufficient but not a necessary contion to achieve the sireoutcome. Non-parallel shifts well twists in the yielcurve cchange the cash flow yielon the immunizing portfolio; however, minimizing the spersion of cash flows in the asset portfolio mitigates this risk. a result, both statements are correct. single liability，matching中，asset的boncoupon和principrepayment可以完美匹配liab到期日和金额，随意没有RI risk和Pririsk。那如果是multiple liabilities呢，matching从后往前找每期bon配liab现金流的时候是否会受到市场利率变动的影响？

2024-03-15 18:28 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018120301000025问题如下 Leahinforms Molly thC ha single $500 million liability e in nineyears, anshe wants SR to construa bonportfolio thearns a rateof return sufficient to poff the obligation. Leexpresses concern aboutthe risks associatewith immunization strategy for this obligation. Inresponse, Molly makes the following statements about liability-iveninvesting:Statement 1: Although the amount ante of SR’s liability is known with certainty, measurement errors associatewith key parameters relative to interest rate changes maersely affethe bonportfolios.Statement 2: A cash flow matching strategy will mitigate the risk from non-parallel shifts in the yielcurve. Whichof Molly’s statements about liability-iven investing is (are) correct? A.Statement 1 only.B.Statement 2 only.C.Both Statement 1 anStatement 2. CorreAnswer: is correct. Molly is correthmeasurement error carise even in immunization strategies for Type 1 cash flows, whihave set amounts anset tes. Also, a parallel shift in yielcurves is a sufficient but not a necessary contion to achieve the sireoutcome. Non-parallel shifts well twists in the yielcurve cchange the cash flow yielon the immunizing portfolio; however, minimizing the spersion of cash flows in the asset portfolio mitigates this risk. a result, both statements are correct. statement2，我记得讲课的时候何老师提到过说matching也会收到利率影响，但是。。。后面忘记了这个地方能再一下吗

2024-03-15 17:38 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018120301000025问题如下 Leahinforms Molly thC ha single $500 million liability e in nineyears, anshe wants SR to construa bonportfolio thearns a rateof return sufficient to poff the obligation. Leexpresses concern aboutthe risks associatewith immunization strategy for this obligation. Inresponse, Molly makes the following statements about liability-iveninvesting:Statement 1: Although the amount ante of SR’s liability is known with certainty, measurement errors associatewith key parameters relative to interest rate changes maersely affethe bonportfolios.Statement 2: A cash flow matching strategy will mitigate the risk from non-parallel shifts in the yielcurve. Whichof Molly’s statements about liability-iven investing is (are) correct? A.Statement 1 only.B.Statement 2 only.C.Both Statement 1 anStatement 2. CorreAnswer: is correct. Molly is correthmeasurement error carise even in immunization strategies for Type 1 cash flows, whihave set amounts anset tes. Also, a parallel shift in yielcurves is a sufficient but not a necessary contion to achieve the sireoutcome. Non-parallel shifts well twists in the yielcurve cchange the cash flow yielon the immunizing portfolio; however, minimizing the spersion of cash flows in the asset portfolio mitigates this risk. a result, both statements are correct. 第二个statement怎么理解呢

2023-12-04 15:17 1 · 回答