开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

guo · 2021年11月22日

为什么不能直接股票换债券

NO.PZ2017121101000012

问题如下:

A $30 million investment account of a bank trust fund is allocated one- third to stocks and two-thirds to bonds. The portfolio manager wants to change the overall allocation to 50% stock and 50% bonds and the allocation within the stock fund from 70% domestic stock and 30% foreign stock to 60% domestic and 40% foreign. The bond allocation will remain entirely invested in domestic corporate issues.

Explain how swaps can be used to implement this adjustment. The market reference rate is assumed to be flat for all swaps, and you do not need to refer to specific stock and bond indexes.

解释:

Currently the allocation is $10 million in stocks and $20 million in bonds. Within the stock category, the current allocation is $7 million domestic and $3 million foreign. The desired allocation is $15 million in stocks and $15 million in bonds. Thus, the allocation must change by moving $5 million into stocks and out of bonds. The desired stock allocation is $9 million domestic and $6 million foreign. The desired bond allocation is $15 million, all domestic corporate.

To make the changes with swaps, the manager must enter into swaps against the market reference rate, which is assumed to be flat for all swaps in this example. Using the swaps, the bank trust fund portfolio manager needs to (1) receive the returns on $2 million based on a domestic equity index and on $3 million based on a foreign equity index and (2) pay the return on $5 million based on a domestic corporate bond index. The market reference rate outflows from the swaps in (1) and the inflows from the swap in (2) will cancel out through summation.

中文解析:

根据题干我们可以梳理出原来的资产配置情况和想要实现的配置情况,如下图:


然后题目想通过互换来实现这个资产配置的改变,于是就有了下图的三个互换(tips:图中的小人代表的是我们所占的一方)


另外,为什么要用MRR作为互换的另一端呢,是因为题干中给到这个信息:“The market reference rate is assumed to be flat for all swaps”。MRR是一个市场利率,常见的如libor。其实这个MRR是什么并不重要,因为在整个操作下来,比如本题的三个互换后,所有关于这个MRR的头寸都被抵消了。当然如果题目没有说要用MRR,我们也可以用libor,或者libor+3%,或者libor+5%都可以的,因为最终对我们是没有影响的。

为什么还要先兑换成mrr呢 这里的flat的意义是什么呢
2 个答案

Hertz_品职助教 · 2022年11月25日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


@ZHANGSHIYI同学你好

问题:如果题干中没提到MRR,是不是可以直接股票换债券?

回答:理论是完全可以的,因为互换是场外衍生品,可以按需定制,没有问题。但实际执行起来是很难找到刚好匹配的对手方的,这一点在上面的回复中也有提到。因此常见的处理方式是本题这样的,找个过渡。

同学说的理论上是完全没有问题的,基于我们现在是三级了,考过之后就是持证人啦,三级会偏向实务一些,所以仍然建议按照题目的处理方式来作答。

----------------------------------------------
加油吧,让我们一起遇见更好的自己!

Hertz_品职助教 · 2021年11月23日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


同学你好~

这里之所以要用MRR做一个过度:

一是因为问题中有一句互换中要使用MRR的导向表述:“The market reference rate is assumed to be flat for all swaps”,其实使用了MRR最后也被抵消掉了;

二是因为这更加实务,是更符合三级的学习水准的。

我们知道互换是场外衍生品,任何两个东西只要可以找到对手方愿意跟你换,随便换什么都可以的,场外合约定制化嘛。

所以理论上将直接将股票和债券的收益互换是没有问题的

但是如果在实务中就有一个问题,就是我们可能找不到恰好可以交换的对手方呀,也可能是在市场上寻找彼此的时间没有碰对,彼此找不到对方,也可能是要换的数量不对等等问题吧,使得直接交换很难发生。

于是就可以找到一个dealer,他在中间做一个过度,就可以很好的实现双方需求的匹配了,此时也就需要MRR作为过度了。

当然这个MRR是多少,是libor还是其他的利率都可以,因为最终被抵消了,只是过渡的作用

----------------------------------------------
虽然现在很辛苦,但努力过的感觉真的很好,加油!

ZHANGSHIYI · 2022年11月24日

如果题干中没提到MRR,是不是可以直接股票换债券?

  • 2

    回答
  • 1

    关注
  • 494

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2017121101000012 问题如下 A $30 million investment account of a bank trust funis allocateone- thirto stocks antwo-thir to bon. The portfolio manager wants to change the overall allocation to 50% stoan50% bon anthe allocation within the stofunfrom 70% mestic stoan30% foreign stoto 60% mestic an40% foreign. The bonallocation will remain entirely investein mestic corporate issues.Explain how swaps cuseto implement this austment. The market referenrate is assumeto flfor all swaps, anyou not neeto refer to specific stoanboninxes. Currently the allocation is $10 million in stocks an$20 million in bon. Within the stocategory, the current allocation is $7 million mestic an$3 million foreign. The sireallocation is $15 million in stocks an$15 million in bon. Thus, the allocation must change moving $5 million into stocks anout of bon. The sirestoallocation is $9 million mestic an$6 million foreign. The sirebonallocation is $15 million, all mestic corporate.To make the changes with swaps, the manager must enter into swaps against the market referenrate, whiis assumeto flfor all swaps in this example. Using the swaps, the bank trust funportfolio manager nee to (1) receive the returns on $2 million baseon a mestic equity inx anon $3 million baseon a foreign equity inx an(2) pthe return on $5 million baseon a mestic corporate boninx. The market referenrate outflows from the swaps in (1) anthe inflows from the swin (2) will cancel out through summation.中文解析根据题干我们可以梳理出原来的资产配置情况和想要实现的配置情况,如下图然后题目想通过互换来实现这个资产配置的改变,于是就有了下图的三个互换(tips图中的小人代表的是我们所占的一方)另外,为什么要用MRR作为互换的另一端呢,是因为题干中给到这个信息“The market referenrate is assumeto flfor all swaps”。MRR是一个市场利率,常见的如libor。其实这个MRR是什么并不重要,因为在整个操作下来,比如本题的三个互换后,所有关于这个MRR的头寸都被抵消了。当然如果题目没有说要用MRR,我们也可以用libor,或者libor+3%,或者libor+5%都可以的,因为最终对我们是没有影响的。 three swaps cuseto implement this austment.the bonposition shoulcrease5m to increase to stoposition.mestic stoincreases 2m, foreign stoincreases 3m.the first swis paying MRR anreceive mestic storeturn with 2m notionprincipalthe seconswis paying MRR anreceive foreign storeturn with 3m notionprincipalthe thirswis paying bonreturn anreceiving MRR with 5m notionprincipal

2023-05-19 12:38 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017121101000012 问题如下 A $30 million investment account of a bank trust funis allocateone- thirto stocks antwo-thir to bon. The portfolio manager wants to change the overall allocation to 50% stoan50% bon anthe allocation within the stofunfrom 70% mestic stoan30% foreign stoto 60% mestic an40% foreign. The bonallocation will remain entirely investein mestic corporate issues.Explain how swaps cuseto implement this austment. The market referenrate is assumeto flfor all swaps, anyou not neeto refer to specific stoanboninxes. Currently the allocation is $10 million in stocks an$20 million in bon. Within the stocategory, the current allocation is $7 million mestic an$3 million foreign. The sireallocation is $15 million in stocks an$15 million in bon. Thus, the allocation must change moving $5 million into stocks anout of bon. The sirestoallocation is $9 million mestic an$6 million foreign. The sirebonallocation is $15 million, all mestic corporate.To make the changes with swaps, the manager must enter into swaps against the market referenrate, whiis assumeto flfor all swaps in this example. Using the swaps, the bank trust funportfolio manager nee to (1) receive the returns on $2 million baseon a mestic equity inx anon $3 million baseon a foreign equity inx an(2) pthe return on $5 million baseon a mestic corporate boninx. The market referenrate outflows from the swaps in (1) anthe inflows from the swin (2) will cancel out through summation.中文解析根据题干我们可以梳理出原来的资产配置情况和想要实现的配置情况,如下图然后题目想通过互换来实现这个资产配置的改变,于是就有了下图的三个互换(tips图中的小人代表的是我们所占的一方)另外,为什么要用MRR作为互换的另一端呢,是因为题干中给到这个信息“The market referenrate is assumeto flfor all swaps”。MRR是一个市场利率,常见的如libor。其实这个MRR是什么并不重要,因为在整个操作下来,比如本题的三个互换后,所有关于这个MRR的头寸都被抵消了。当然如果题目没有说要用MRR,我们也可以用libor,或者libor+3%,或者libor+5%都可以的,因为最终对我们是没有影响的。 这道题干说投的是bonstock没说是boninx答案是怎么看出来投了inx?【mestic equity inx 】

2022-06-01 07:26 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2017121101000012 问题如下 A $30 million investment account of a bank trust funis allocateone- thirto stocks antwo-thir to bon. The portfolio manager wants to change the overall allocation to 50% stoan50% bon anthe allocation within the stofunfrom 70% mestic stoan30% foreign stoto 60% mestic an40% foreign. The bonallocation will remain entirely investein mestic corporate issues.Explain how swaps cuseto implement this austment. The market referenrate is assumeto flfor all swaps, anyou not neeto refer to specific stoanboninxes. Currently the allocation is $10 million in stocks an$20 million in bon. Within the stocategory, the current allocation is $7 million mestic an$3 million foreign. The sireallocation is $15 million in stocks an$15 million in bon. Thus, the allocation must change moving $5 million into stocks anout of bon. The sirestoallocation is $9 million mestic an$6 million foreign. The sirebonallocation is $15 million, all mestic corporate.To make the changes with swaps, the manager must enter into swaps against the market referenrate, whiis assumeto flfor all swaps in this example. Using the swaps, the bank trust funportfolio manager nee to (1) receive the returns on $2 million baseon a mestic equity inx anon $3 million baseon a foreign equity inx an(2) pthe return on $5 million baseon a mestic corporate boninx. The market referenrate outflows from the swaps in (1) anthe inflows from the swin (2) will cancel out through summation.中文解析根据题干我们可以梳理出原来的资产配置情况和想要实现的配置情况,如下图然后题目想通过互换来实现这个资产配置的改变,于是就有了下图的三个互换(tips图中的小人代表的是我们所占的一方)另外,为什么要用MRR作为互换的另一端呢,是因为题干中给到这个信息“The market referenrate is assumeto flfor all swaps”。MRR是一个市场利率,常见的如libor。其实这个MRR是什么并不重要,因为在整个操作下来,比如本题的三个互换后,所有关于这个MRR的头寸都被抵消了。当然如果题目没有说要用MRR,我们也可以用libor,或者libor+3%,或者libor+5%都可以的,因为最终对我们是没有影响的。 我是这么写的he center 3 swaps:receive mestic storeturn, pmarket referenrate, notionprincipof $2m.receive foreign storeturn, pmarket referenrate, notionprincipof $3m.pbonreturn, receive market referenrate, notionprincipof $5m.还需要写金额咋分析出来的、MRR相互抵消之类的吗?

2022-05-29 11:59 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017121101000012问题如下A $30 million investment account of a bank trust funis allocateone- thirto stocks antwo-thir to bon. The portfolio manager wants to change the overall allocation to 50% stoan50% bon anthe allocation within the stofunfrom 70% mestic stoan30% foreign stoto 60% mestic an40% foreign. The bonallocation will remain entirely investein mestic corporate issues.Explain how swaps cuseto implement this austment. The market referenrate is assumeto flfor all swaps, anyou not neeto refer to specific stoanboninxes. Currently the allocation is $10 million in stocks an$20 million in bon. Within the stocategory, the current allocation is $7 million mestic an$3 million foreign. The sireallocation is $15 million in stocks an$15 million in bon. Thus, the allocation must change moving $5 million into stocks anout of bon. The sirestoallocation is $9 million mestic an$6 million foreign. The sirebonallocation is $15 million, all mestic corporate.To make the changes with swaps, the manager must enter into swaps against the market referenrate, whiis assumeto flfor all swaps in this example. Using the swaps, the bank trust funportfolio manager nee to (1) receive the returns on $2 million baseon a mestic equity inx anon $3 million baseon a foreign equity inx an(2) pthe return on $5 million baseon a mestic corporate boninx. The market referenrate outflows from the swaps in (1) anthe inflows from the swin (2) will cancel out through summation.中文解析根据题干我们可以梳理出原来的资产配置情况和想要实现的配置情况,如下图然后题目想通过互换来实现这个资产配置的改变,于是就有了下图的三个互换(tips图中的小人代表的是我们所占的一方)另外,为什么要用MRR作为互换的另一端呢,是因为题干中给到这个信息“The market referenrate is assumeto flfor all swaps”。MRR是一个市场利率,常见的如libor。其实这个MRR是什么并不重要,因为在整个操作下来,比如本题的三个互换后,所有关于这个MRR的头寸都被抵消了。当然如果题目没有说要用MRR,我们也可以用libor,或者libor+3%,或者libor+5%都可以的,因为最终对我们是没有影响的。 the portfolio's current asset allocation is:- $10 million in stocks, whicombines of $7 million mestic stoan$3 million foreign stock.- $20 million mestic corporate bonhe portfolio's asset allocation after austment is:- $15 million in stocks, whicombines of $9 million mestic stoan$6 million foreign stock.- $15 million mestic corporate bonhe swaps cuse1. use mestic corporate boninx exchange for mestic stoinx with $2 million notionprincipal;2. use mestic corporate boninx exchange for foreign stoinx with $3 million notionprincipal;老师,我在其他问答里,勉强看懂了为什么要用MRR作为中间互换资产的原因,红字部分是我的作答,对比来看应该不妥。 想问下回答这个问题时,英文有没有推荐的表述?我感觉答案的写法也很绕,没有直观体现每一笔都用MRR去互换

2022-04-13 11:08 2 · 回答