开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

贝就要贝到底 · 2021年04月26日

Condor和butterfly的区别

NO.PZ2019103001000040

问题如下:

McLaughlin and Michaela Donaldson, a junior analyst at Delphi, are now discussing how to reposition the portfolio in light of McLaughlin’s expectations about interest rates over the next 12 months. She expects interest rate volatility to be high and the yield curve to experience an increase in the 2s/10s/30s butterfly spread, with the 30-year yield remaining unchanged. Selected yields on the Treasury yield curve, and McLaughlin’s expected changes in yields over the next 12 months, are presented in Exhibit 1.

After recommending a portfolio strategy, McLaughlin tells Donaldson that using a duration-neutral, long/short structure may be a better strategy for attempting to enhance portfolio return. McLaughlin suggests that Donaldson consider a butterfly trade or a condor trade using some combination of 2-year, 5-year, 10-year, and 30-year bonds.

Given McLaughlin’s interest rate expectations over the next 12 months, which long/short structure would be most appropriate?

选项:

A.

Condor: short wings, long body

B.

Butterfly: short barbell, long bullet

C.

Butterfly: long barbell, short bullet

解释:

C is correct.

McLaughlin expects interest rate volatility to be high and the yield curve to experience an increase in the butterfly spread, with the 30-year yield remaining unchanged. Given these expectations, a long barbell (2s and 30s, short bullet [10s] butterfly trade would be most appropriate. The two-year yield is expected to slightly increase by 0.04%, resulting in minimal price impact given the relatively low duration of two-year bonds. Similarly, the 30-year yield is expected to remain constant, resulting in minimal price impact as well. The 10-year yield (+0.50%) is expected to increase by more than the 5-year yield (+0.40%), and with its higher effective duration, the 10-year would be appropriate for the short bullet part of the butterfly trade.

如果A选项是Short Body, Long wing, 这道题是选condor还是选butterfly呢

1 个答案
已采纳答案

发亮_品职助教 · 2021年04月28日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


Condor和butterfly的区别


没什么本质区别,可以理解他们俩没有区别


Condor策略更加细腻一些,因为他有两个中期利率头寸;Butterfly策略会更加粗犷一些,因为Butterfly只有1个中期利率头寸。

首先需要明确的是,condor策略和Butterfly策略,都是Long/Short的策略,目的是捕获收益率曲线上,中期利率相对于长、短期利率的变动。

其中Body(Bullet)是指Condor与Butterlfy里的中期利率头寸,Wings(barbell)是指Condor与Butterfly里的短期、长期利率头寸。


下面举个例子大概说明一下为啥两者策略一样,且condor策略因为有2个中期利率会更加细腻。


假设,短期利率2-year利率下降,中期利率5year ~ 10year这段区间利率上升,长期利率30-year利率下降。这是收益率曲线上,中期利率相对于短期利率、长期利率的改变,那我们就可以使用Condor与butterfly策略来赚取收益。


那使用Butterfly策略的话应该是:Long 2-year,Short 10-year,Long 30-year;这样中期利率上升,中期债券价格下降,Short 10-year中期债券可以获利;

长期、短期利率下降,长期、短期债券价格上升,Long长期30-year、短期2-year债券可以有收益。这样Butterfly的Long/Short策略能赚取收益。


用Condor策略做的话就是:Long 2-year,Short 5-year,Short 10-year,Long 30-year;这样也可以赚取中期债券价格下降带来的收益,短期、长期债券价格上升带来的收益。

但是我们发现,Condor策略有2个中期利率,这样是把收益率曲线分的更细,可以捕捉到收益率曲线上更加细节的变化。

例如,Long 2-year short 5-year,其实捕捉到了中期利率5-year相对于短期利率2-year的变化;

而Short 10-year,Long 30-year,其实捕捉到了中期利率10-year相对于长期利率30-year的变化。


反观Butterfly,只能捕捉到一个中期利率的变动。


所以Condor与Butterfly是差不多的策略,没有本质区别,他们都是捕捉中期利率相对的变化,但Condor由于有2个中期利率,因此他会更加细腻。


如果A选项是Short Body, Long wing, 这道题是选condor还是选butterfly呢


根据这道题的利率曲线变动: the yield curve to experience an increase in the 2s/10s/30s butterfly spread, with the 30-year yield remaining unchanged. 

即,中期利率10-year相对上升;

那这样的话,无论是使用Butterfly策略,还是使用Condor策略,都应该是Short中期债券,即,Short body(Short bullet)。

由于是Long/Short策略,Short body就需要Long wings(Long barbell);


于是,不论是使用Butterfly还是Condor,在本题的利率预期下,都是:Long wings(Barbell), Short body(Bullet)。


首先C选项肯定是正确的。然后把A选项改成提问里的说法,A选项也是正确的。定性判断的话,改动之后的A与C选项都正确哈,我们考试只会考到定性判断,且考试只有一个正确选项;改动之后的A与C选项一定要选一个最优的话,可能需要结合其他限制定量计算了,我们教材就没再涉及了哈。

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版,加油!

jjj198918 · 2021年07月29日

这个回答又详细又清晰!非常有帮助!