开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

毛线 · 2021年02月10日

老师这题是不是因为已知了正态分布,所以不用标准化,得出来的概率就可以直接比较大小?

NO.PZ2017092702000100

问题如下:

An analyst develops the following capital market projections.

Assuming the returns of the asset classes are described by normal distributions, which of the following statements is correct?

选项:

A.

Bonds have a higher probability of a negative return than stocks.

B.

On average, 99% of stock returns will fall within two standard deviations of the mean.

C.

The probability of a bond return less than or equal to 3% is determined using a Z-score of 0.25.

解释:

A is correct.

The chance of a negative return falls in the area to the left of 0% under a standard normal curve. By standardizing the returns and standard deviations of the two assets, the likelihood of either asset experiencing a negative return may be determined: Z-score (standardized value) = (X – μ)/σ Z-score for a bond return of 0% = (0 – 2)/5 = –0.40. Z-score for a stock return of 0% = (0 – 10)/15 = –0.67. For bonds, a 0% return falls 0.40 standard deviations below the mean return of 2%. In contrast, for stocks, a 0% return falls 0.67 standard deviations below the mean return of 10%. A standard deviation of 0.40 is less than a standard deviation of 0.67. Negative returns thus occupy more of the left tail of the bond distribution than the stock distribution. Thus, bonds are more likely than stocks to experience a negative return.

老师这题是不是因为已知了正态分布,所以不用标准化,得出来的概率就可以直接比较大小?

2 个答案

星星_品职助教 · 2021年02月11日

@毛线 回复追问:

不需要查表,仍以A选项为例。

通过图②可以看出,这个时候已经能看出来bond对应的概率面积肯定比stock对应的面积大了。这个时候就已经可以得到结论:“Bonds have a higher probability of a negative return (than stocks)”。没有必要再去查表了。

查表的目的也是查出对应的面积是多少,如果此时查表,可以查出来bond对应的概率面积是多大,stock对应的概率面积是多大。最后得出的结论依然是bond对应概率面积更大。而这个结论我们已经知道了,就不需要再做查表的这一步了。

星星_品职助教 · 2021年02月10日

同学你好,

这道题还是需要做标准化的,以A选项为例,虽然bond和stock都是服从正态分布,但是这两个正态分布并不一样,比较的基准不同,无法直接进行对比(见图①)。

只能在转化到标准正态分布后,此刻分布相同(都是同一个标准正态分布),才可以进行比较。

bond的收益率为负的概率,在bond对应的普通正态分布下需要求的是P(X<0%)

所以P(X<0%)转化为P(z<(0%-2%)/5%)=P(z<-0.4);同理,stock收益率为负的概率标准化后为P(z<-0.67),由于-0.67落在了-0.40的左侧,对应的面积小,所以可以得出:stock收益率为负的概率<bond收益率为负的概率(见图②)。

  • 2

    回答
  • 3

    关注
  • 1051

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2017092702000100问题如下 analyst velops the following capitmarket projections.Assuming the returns of the asset classes are scribenormstributions, whiof the following statements is correct?A.Bon have a higher probability of a negative return thstocks.B.On average, 99% of storeturns will fall within two stanrviations of the mean.C.The probability of a bonreturn less thor equto 3% is termineusing a Z-score of 0.25.A is correct.The chanof a negative return falls in the area to the left of 0% unr a stanrnormcurve. stanrzing the returns anstanrviations of the two assets, the likelihooof either asset experiencing a negative return mtermine Z-score (stanrzevalue) = (X – μ)/σ Z-score for a bonreturn of 0% = (0 – 2)/5 = –0.40. Z-score for a storeturn of 0% = (0 – 10)/15 = –0.67. For bon, a 0% return falls 0.40 stanrviations below the mereturn of 2%. In contrast, for stocks, a 0% return falls 0.67 stanrviations below the mereturn of 10%. A stanrviation of 0.40 is less tha stanrviation of 0.67. Negative returns thus occupy more of the left tail of the bonstribution ththe stostribution. Thus, bon are more likely thstocks to experiena negative return.A可以用 标准差/平均 来比较吗C要怎么算呢

2022-09-21 07:28 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017092702000100问题如下analyst velops the following capitmarket projections.Assuming the returns of the asset classes are scribenormstributions, whiof the following statements is correct?A.Bon have a higher probability of a negative return thstocks.B.On average, 99% of storeturns will fall within two stanrviations of the mean.C.The probability of a bonreturn less thor equto 3% is termineusing a Z-score of 0.25.A is correct.The chanof a negative return falls in the area to the left of 0% unr a stanrnormcurve. stanrzing the returns anstanrviations of the two assets, the likelihooof either asset experiencing a negative return mtermine Z-score (stanrzevalue) = (X – μ)/σ Z-score for a bonreturn of 0% = (0 – 2)/5 = –0.40. Z-score for a storeturn of 0% = (0 – 10)/15 = –0.67. For bon, a 0% return falls 0.40 stanrviations below the mereturn of 2%. In contrast, for stocks, a 0% return falls 0.67 stanrviations below the mereturn of 10%. A stanrviation of 0.40 is less tha stanrviation of 0.67. Negative returns thus occupy more of the left tail of the bonstribution ththe stostribution. Thus, bon are more likely thstocks to experiena negative return.老师请问A要怎么计算

2022-09-09 22:07 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017092702000100问题如下analyst velops the following capitmarket projections.Assuming the returns of the asset classes are scribenormstributions, whiof the following statements is correct?A.Bon have a higher probability of a negative return thstocks.B.On average, 99% of storeturns will fall within two stanrviations of the mean.C.The probability of a bonreturn less thor equto 3% is termineusing a Z-score of 0.25.A is correct.The chanof a negative return falls in the area to the left of 0% unr a stanrnormcurve. stanrzing the returns anstanrviations of the two assets, the likelihooof either asset experiencing a negative return mtermine Z-score (stanrzevalue) = (X – μ)/σ Z-score for a bonreturn of 0% = (0 – 2)/5 = –0.40. Z-score for a storeturn of 0% = (0 – 10)/15 = –0.67. For bon, a 0% return falls 0.40 stanrviations below the mereturn of 2%. In contrast, for stocks, a 0% return falls 0.67 stanrviations below the mereturn of 10%. A stanrviation of 0.40 is less tha stanrviation of 0.67. Negative returns thus occupy more of the left tail of the bonstribution ththe stostribution. Thus, bon are more likely thstocks to experiena negative return.可以把B答案翻译一下吗?

2022-07-10 21:43 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2017092702000100问题如下 analyst velops the following capitmarket projections.Assuming the returns of the asset classes are scribenormstributions, whiof the following statements is correct?A.Bon have a higher probability of a negative return thstocks.B.On average, 99% of storeturns will fall within two stanrviations of the mean.C.The probability of a bonreturn less thor equto 3% is termineusing a Z-score of 0.25.A is correct.The chanof a negative return falls in the area to the left of 0% unr a stanrnormcurve. stanrzing the returns anstanrviations of the two assets, the likelihooof either asset experiencing a negative return mtermine Z-score (stanrzevalue) = (X – μ)/σ Z-score for a bonreturn of 0% = (0 – 2)/5 = –0.40. Z-score for a storeturn of 0% = (0 – 10)/15 = –0.67. For bon, a 0% return falls 0.40 stanrviations below the mereturn of 2%. In contrast, for stocks, a 0% return falls 0.67 stanrviations below the mereturn of 10%. A stanrviation of 0.40 is less tha stanrviation of 0.67. Negative returns thus occupy more of the left tail of the bonstribution ththe stostribution. Thus, bon are more likely thstocks to experiena negative return.同上,英文版的不太看得懂

2022-07-06 14:07 2 · 回答