问题如下图:
文章倒数第二段不是有提到根据past experience 这种strategy 是有效的?为什么不是representative bias
选项:
A.
B.
C.
解释:
Shimin_CPA税法主讲、CFA教研 · 2017年12月06日
这题用排除法。Jordan是overconfidence bias,题干用了大量的文字描述,AC表现的很明显。B, representativeness bias用以前的套路分析新的信息,这题没有分析新的信息,本质上还是因为Jordan太自信认定这个策略以后也是有效的。
Shimin_CPA税法主讲、CFA教研 · 2017年12月06日
补充一下:原版书123页提到这个是naive extrapolation of past returns
kevinyemingyu · 2017年12月09日
不是很明白,小助手提这个naive extrapolation of past returns 是什么意思
NO.PZ201511190100000306 问题如下 Whione of the following biases Jorn not monstrate? A.Self-attribution. B.Representativeness. C.Illusion of knowlee. B is correct.Nowhere in the scenario it mention thJorn classifiecertain information into a personalizecategory. Representativeness biis a cognitive biin whipeople tento classify new information baseon past experiences anclassifications. Jorn is not relating the certainty about the future or her cision to hollosing positions bato something she hne or experiencein the past. 这个bias感觉没讲过,也很少考到。这道题哪里体现了呢
NO.PZ201511190100000306问题如下Whione of the following biases Jorn not monstrate? A.Self-attribution. B.Representativeness. C.Illusion of knowlee. B is correct.Nowhere in the scenario it mention thJorn classifiecertain information into a personalizecategory. Representativeness biis a cognitive biin whipeople tento classify new information baseon past experiences anclassifications. Jorn is not relating the certainty about the future or her cision to hollosing positions bato something she hne or experiencein the past.A在哪里体现了?
NO.PZ201511190100000306 一方面,通过representativeness bias与conservatism bias的辨析来学习,可以理解较透彻,Base-rate negleansample-size neglect也能理解地很好。对于此题而言,如果representativeness bias是对新信息overreact,那么文中主人公对价格反转的坚信,就算表现了什么,也应该是conservatism bias。 另一方面,教材对representativeness bias的定义又看得很难受,people tento classify new information baseon past experiences anclassifications,一下子搞得文中主人公的行为似乎也符合这种定义。 所以,真的是对representiveness bias很晕
NO.PZ201511190100000306 Representativeness. Illusion of knowlee. B is correct. Nowhere in the scenario it mention thJorn classifiecertain information into a personalizecategory. Representativeness biis a cognitive biin whipeople tento classify new information baseon past experiences anclassifications. Jorn is not relating the certainty about the future or her cision to hollosing positions bato something she hne or experiencein the past.请问老师,他说策略之前表现的好为什么没有represenetatives呢?
NO.PZ201511190100000306 倒数第二段She reassures the teththis strategy hperformewell in the past anththe markets will revert anthe funs returns will return to normlevels.这句话就表明了jorn根据过去的经验判断未来啊