开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

LHY · 2020年08月01日

问一道题:NO.PZ2016072602000029

问题如下:

Consider a bank that wants to have an amount of capital so that it can absorb unexpected losses corresponding to a firmwide VAR at the 1 % level. It measures firmwide VAR by adding up the VARs for market risk, operational risk, and credit risk. There is a risk that the bank has too little capital because

选项:

A.

It does not take into account the correlations among risks.

B.

It ignores risks that are not market, operational, or credit risks.

C.

It mistakenly uses VAR to measure operational risk because operational risks that matter are rare events.

D.

It is meaningless to add VARs.

解释:

B is correct. VAR can be added across different types of risk, but this will provide a conservative estimate of capital as diversification effects are ignored. So answer a. would be for too much capital. Answer c. is not correct because rare events can be factored into operational VAR. Most likely, the bank may have too little capital for other types of risk than those measured by these three categories.

我的理解:

题目大意:

公司想有大量的足够覆盖UL的capital(99%VAR),然后算了market和credit这类主流量化计量的风险,并简单相加得到公司的VAR,但是还是发现自己的capital太少了,原因是什么?


那我觉得a答案是符合逻辑的啊,因为它只是把各个类型的var加总起来,忽律相互之间的分散性,导致了firm var远大于实际,显得自己的capital很小。


请问下我的理解是哪里出了问题?


1 个答案

袁园_品职助教 · 2020年08月03日

同学你好!

题目理解没问题。

A选项说直接相加了,没有考虑到相关性,那么这样直接相加得到的VaR 对应 capital理应是最大的,是高估不是低估

B选项说他还有些风险没有识别,也就没有加在capital里所以现在capital还偏小

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 451

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2016072602000029 问题如下 Consir a bank thwants to have an amount of capitso thit cabsorb unexpectelosses corresponng to a firmwi Vthe 1 % level. It measures firmwi Vaing up the VARs for market risk, operationrisk, ancret risk. There is a risk ththe bank htoo little capitbecause It es not take into account the correlations among risks. It ignores risks thare not market, operational, or cret risks. It mistakenly uses Vto measure operationrisk because operationrisks thmatter are rare events. It is meaningless to a VARs. B is correct. Vcaeacross fferent types of risk, but this will provi a conservative estimate of capitversification effects are ignore So answer woulfor too much capital. Answer is not correbecause rare events cfactoreinto operational VAR. Most likely, the bank mhave too little capitfor other types of risk ththose measurethese three categories. 如题

2024-04-16 18:48 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016072602000029问题如下 Consir a bank thwants to have an amount of capitso thit cabsorb unexpectelosses corresponng to a firmwi Vthe 1 % level. It measures firmwi Vaing up the VARs for market risk, operationrisk, ancret risk. There is a risk ththe bank htoo little capitbecause It es not take into account the correlations among risks. It ignores risks thare not market, operational, or cret risks. It mistakenly uses Vto measure operationrisk because operationrisks thmatter are rare events. It is meaningless to a VARs. B is correct. Vcaeacross fferent types of risk, but this will provi a conservative estimate of capitversification effects are ignore So answer woulfor too much capital. Answer is not correbecause rare events cfactoreinto operational VAR. Most likely, the bank mhave too little capitfor other types of risk ththose measurethese three categories. 除了CR.MR OR还有什么风险?战略,声誉之类的吗?

2023-04-25 16:19 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2016072602000029 问题如下 Consir a bank thwants to have an amount of capitso thit cabsorb unexpectelosses corresponng to a firmwi Vthe 1 % level. It measures firmwi Vaing up the VARs for market risk, operationrisk, ancret risk. There is a risk ththe bank htoo little capitbecause It es not take into account the correlations among risks. It ignores risks thare not market, operational, or cret risks. It mistakenly uses Vto measure operationrisk because operationrisks thmatter are rare events. It is meaningless to a VARs. B is correct. Vcaeacross fferent types of risk, but this will provi a conservative estimate of capitversification effects are ignore So answer woulfor too much capital. Answer is not correbecause rare events cfactoreinto operational VAR. Most likely, the bank mhave too little capitfor other types of risk ththose measurethese three categories. 所以可以直接相加为什么是错的?

2022-11-15 05:53 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016072602000029 It ignores risks thare not market, operational, or cret risks. It mistakenly uses Vto measure operationrisk because operationrisks thmatter are rare events. It is meaningless to a VARs. B is correct. Vcaeacross fferent types of risk, but this will provi a conservative estimate of capitversification effects are ignore So answer woulfor too mucapital. Answer is not correbecause rare events cfactoreinto operationVAR. Most likely, the bank mhave too little capitfor other types of risk ththose measurethese three categories. 既然算出来的值太小,那不会应该操作失误,譬如输入错误数据不足等这之类的数据令本该大的值却变小了吗?

2021-11-15 12:08 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2016072602000029 It ignores risks thare not market, operational, or cret risks. It mistakenly uses Vto measure operationrisk because operationrisks thmatter are rare events. It is meaningless to a VARs. B is correct. Vcaeacross fferent types of risk, but this will provi a conservative estimate of capitversification effects are ignore So answer woulfor too mucapital. Answer is not correbecause rare events cfactoreinto operationVAR. Most likely, the bank mhave too little capitfor other types of risk ththose measurethese three categories. 问题如上问题如上问题如上

2021-04-28 21:28 2 · 回答