开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

Ruthlessbaby · 2020年02月24日

问一道题:NO.PZ2020020202000014

问题如下:

The next day, Harding instructs Yellow to revisit their research on BYYP, Inc. Yellow’s research leads her to believe that its shares are undervalued. She shares her research with Harding, and at 10 a.m. he instructs her to buy 120,000 shares when the price is $40.00 using a limit order of $42.00.
The buy-side trader releases the order for market execution when the price is $40.50. The only fee is a commission of $0.02 per share. By the end of the trading day, 90,000 shares of the order had been purchased, and BYYP closes at $42.50. The trade was executed at an average price of $41.42. Details about the executed trades are presented in Exhibit 1.

The arrival cost for purchasing the 90,000 shares of BYYP is:

选项:

A.

164.4 bp.

B.

227.2 bp.

C.

355.0 bp.

解释:

B is correct.

The arrival cost is calculated as:
Arrival cost (bp) =Side×PP0P0×104bp=+1×41.4240.5040.50×104bp=227.2bpSide\times\frac{\overline P-P_0}{P_0}\times10^4bp=+1\times\frac{41.42-40.50}{40.50}\times10^4bp=227.2bp

IS COST 试用的p0是decision 时候的市场价格,而arrival cost 使用的p0是该比订单发出时的市场价格, IS cost 和 arrival cost 的本质区别是什么?怎么理解

1 个答案

吴昊_品职助教 · 2020年02月24日

完全是两个不同的概念,不能混为一谈。

Implementation shortfall本质是paper return和actual return之间的差额,是对于交易成本的分解,共分成了execution cost,opportunity cost,fees。execution cost可以再细分为delay cost和trading cost。

Trading cost交易成本是用来衡量交易执行的好坏的,本题中的arrival cost是拿arrival price来作为benchmark。

  • 1

    回答
  • 6

    关注
  • 1587

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2020020202000014 问题如下 The next y, Harng instructs Yellow to revisit their researon BYYP, InYellow’s researlea her to believe thits shares are unrvalue She shares her researwith Harng, an10 a.m. he instructs her to buy 120,000 shares when the priis $40.00 using a limit orr of $42.00.The buy-si trar releases the orr for market execution when the priis $40.50. The only fee is a commission of $0.02 per share. the enof the trang y, 90,000 shares of the orr hbeen purchase anBYYP closes $42.50. The tra wexecuteaverage priof $41.42. tails about the executetras are presentein Exhibit 1.The arrivcost for purchasing the 90,000 shares of BYYP is: A.164.4 bp. B.227.2 bp. C.355.0 bp. B is correct.The arrivcost is calculateas:Arrivcost (bp) =Si×P‾−P0P0×104bp=+1×41.42−40.5040.50×104bp=227.2bpSi\times\frac{\overline P-P_0}{P_0}\times10^4bp=+1\times\frac{41.42-40.50}{40.50}\times10^4bp=227.2bpSi×P0​P−P0​​×104bp=+1×40.5041.42−40.50​×104bp=227.2 请问为什么这里的referenprice是40.5,但是后面算implementation shortfall时referenprice就是用的40呢?应该从什么角度去理解可以记住呀?谢谢

2024-05-08 07:29 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2020020202000014 问题如下 The next y, Harng instructs Yellow to revisit their researon BYYP, InYellow’s researlea her to believe thits shares are unrvalue She shares her researwith Harng, an10 a.m. he instructs her to buy 120,000 shares when the priis $40.00 using a limit orr of $42.00.The buy-si trar releases the orr for market execution when the priis $40.50. The only fee is a commission of $0.02 per share. the enof the trang y, 90,000 shares of the orr hbeen purchase anBYYP closes $42.50. The tra wexecuteaverage priof $41.42. tails about the executetras are presentein Exhibit 1.The arrivcost for purchasing the 90,000 shares of BYYP is: A.164.4 bp. B.227.2 bp. C.355.0 bp. B is correct.The arrivcost is calculateas:Arrivcost (bp) =Si×P‾−P0P0×104bp=+1×41.42−40.5040.50×104bp=227.2bpSi\times\frac{\overline P-P_0}{P_0}\times10^4bp=+1\times\frac{41.42-40.50}{40.50}\times10^4bp=227.2bpSi×P0​P−P0​​×104bp=+1×40.5041.42−40.50​×104bp=227.2 这道题如果要求计算implementation short fall,那cision price是否应该是40?

2023-02-20 12:04 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2020020202000014 问题如下 The next y, Harng instructs Yellow to revisit their researon BYYP, InYellow’s researlea her to believe thits shares are unrvalue She shares her researwith Harng, an10 a.m. he instructs her to buy 120,000 shares when the priis $40.00 using a limit orr of $42.00.The buy-si trar releases the orr for market execution when the priis $40.50. The only fee is a commission of $0.02 per share. the enof the trang y, 90,000 shares of the orr hbeen purchase anBYYP closes $42.50. The tra wexecuteaverage priof $41.42. tails about the executetras are presentein Exhibit 1.The arrivcost for purchasing the 90,000 shares of BYYP is: A.164.4 bp. B.227.2 bp. C.355.0 bp. B is correct.The arrivcost is calculateas:Arrivcost (bp) =Si×P‾−P0P0×104bp=+1×41.42−40.5040.50×104bp=227.2bpSi\times\frac{\overline P-P_0}{P_0}\times10^4bp=+1\times\frac{41.42-40.50}{40.50}\times10^4bp=227.2bpSi×P0​P−P0​​×104bp=+1×40.5041.42−40.50​×104bp=227.2 根据implemention shortfall/ expanimplemention shortfall 也只有这几类 Execution cost; lcost; Trang cost; Opportunity cost, Fee. 这个arrivcost 是等价于trang cost 吗?

2023-01-30 16:45 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2020020202000014 227.2 bp. 355.0 bp. B is correct. The arrivcost is calculateas: Arrivcost (bp) = Si×P‾−P0P0×104bp=+1×41.42−40.5040.50×104bp=227.2bpSi\times\frac{\overline P-P_0}{P_0}\times10^4bp=+1\times\frac{41.42-40.50}{40.50}\times10^4bp=227.2bpSi×P0​P−P0​​×104bp=+1×40.5041.42−40.50​×104bp=227.2arrivprice是投资传达给交易员时的价格,还是交易员传达给市场时的价格?

2022-02-12 20:38 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2020020202000014 老师这个cost的计算都是不考虑fee的吗?

2021-03-23 16:28 1 · 回答