开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

James · 2025年03月28日

这道题的解题思路

NO.PZ2023040501000124

问题如下:

Andrei prepares a Beneish Model analysis, shown in Exhibit 3, to assess the likelihood that Galaxy is manipulating its earnings. He recalls that an M-score of –1.78 corresponds to a probability of earnings manipulation of 3.8%.

Exhibit 3 Galaxy 2014 Beneish Model M-Score Determination


Which of the following from Andrei’s Beneish M-score determination is the best indicator that Galaxy could be manipulating earnings?

选项:

A.

The total M-score

B.

The days sales in receivable index

C.

The leverage index

解释:

B is correct. A DSRI (days sales in receivable index) greater than 1 indicates an inappropriate relationship between accounts receivable and revenue recognition and is a potential signal of earnings manipulation. For Galaxy, it is the largest positive contributor (DSRI = 1.619) that would increase the M score. Larger values for the M-score (and contributors) are more indicative of earnings manipulation. Increasing leverage could predispose a company to manipulate earnings, but here the leverage index is negative indicating that leverage has decreased.

A is incorrect. Higher M-scores (less negative) indicate an increased probability of earnings manipulation. Here the lower (more negative score) would indicate that the company is less likely to be manipulating earnings.

C is incorrect. Increasing leverage could predispose a company to manipulate earnings, but here the leverage index is negative, indicating that leverage has decreased.

因为总的M score是负数,比较小所以无法认定操纵。但拆分来看,第一个因子的contribution 是最大的,所以这个因子是最有可能操纵的。


这样来理解对吗?

1 个答案

王园圆_品职助教 · 2025年03月29日

同学你好,不对

an M-score of –1.78 corresponds to a probability of earnings manipulation of 3.8%”题干说了这个,然后表格又说M -score是 - 3.83,比-1.78低的多——而M score是越高才越说明公司有操纵Earnings的可能性的,那单看M score只能说明公司没有操纵NI,这和t题目要求的就相违背了,所以A选项才不能选

相反,B选项的days sales in receivable index对整个M score是有正向的增加作用的,说明它确实会导致M score更高,也就是这个项目的增加会使公司操纵NI的可能性变高了


  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 3

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023040501000124问题如下 Anei prepares a Beneish Mol analysis, shown in Exhibit 3, to assess the likelihoothGalaxy is manipulating its earnings. He recalls thM-score of –1.78 correspon to a probability of earnings manipulation of 3.8%.Exhibit 3 Galaxy 2014 Beneish Mol M-Score terminationWhiof the following from Anei’s Beneish M-score termination is the best incator thGalaxy coulmanipulating earnings? A.The totM-scoreB.The ys sales in receivable inxC.The leverage inx B is correct. A RI (ys sales in receivable inx) greater th1 incates inappropriate relationship between accounts receivable anrevenue recognition anis a potentisignof earnings manipulation. For Galaxy, it is the largest positive contributor (RI = 1.619) thwoulincrease the M score. Larger values for the M-score (ancontributors) are more incative of earnings manipulation. Increasing leverage coulprespose a company to manipulate earnings, but here the leverage inx is negative incating thleverage hcreaseA is incorrect. Higher M-scores (less negative) incate increaseprobability of earnings manipulation. Here the lower (more negative score) woulincate ththe company is less likely to manipulating earnings.C is incorrect. Increasing leverage coulprespose a company to manipulate earnings, but here the leverage inx is negative, incating thleverage hcrease RI大于1为什么就有操作可能呢

2024-08-21 22:03 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2023040501000124 问题如下 Anei prepares a Beneish Mol analysis, shown in Exhibit 3, to assess the likelihoothGalaxy is manipulating its earnings. He recalls thM-score of –1.78 correspon to a probability of earnings manipulation of 3.8%.Exhibit 3 Galaxy 2014 Beneish Mol M-Score terminationWhiof the following from Anei’s Beneish M-score termination is the best incator thGalaxy coulmanipulating earnings? A.The totM-score B.The ys sales in receivable inx C.The leverage inx B is correct. A RI (ys sales in receivable inx) greater th1 incates inappropriate relationship between accounts receivable anrevenue recognition anis a potentisignof earnings manipulation. For Galaxy, it is the largest positive contributor (RI = 1.619) thwoulincrease the M score. Larger values for the M-score (ancontributors) are more incative of earnings manipulation. Increasing leverage coulprespose a company to manipulate earnings, but here the leverage inx is negative incating thleverage hcreaseA is incorrect. Higher M-scores (less negative) incate increaseprobability of earnings manipulation. Here the lower (more negative score) woulincate ththe company is less likely to manipulating earnings.C is incorrect. Increasing leverage coulprespose a company to manipulate earnings, but here the leverage inx is negative, incating thleverage hcrease 这题问的是啥意思,M-score不就是用来看操纵概率的么,为什么还问别的。

2024-07-18 10:38 1 · 回答