开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

梦梦 · 2024年11月10日

控制蒙特卡洛模拟方差的方法

NO.PZ2023091601000099

问题如下:

A risk manager at a hedge fund wants to conduct a simulation to forecast the stock price of a particular company at a future date. The manager aims to achieve this by simulating the values of a European option and an Asian option on the company’s stock that mature on the specified future date, and considers several methods to improve the accuracy of the simulation. Which of the following statements is correct regarding the methods typically used to reduce sampling error?

选项:

A.

Antithetic variables introduce a set of random variables that are positively correlated with the simulation variables to reduce the number of replications.

B.

Control variates and antithetic variables both reduce bootstrapping sampling variability for a given number of replications.

C.

The use of control variates is limited to simulations in which there is a closed-form solution with which to compare the simulated outcome.

D.

The application of control variates involves employing a variable with a mean of zero and a strong positive correlation with the simulated values.

解释:

D is correct. This is the definition of control variates.

A is incorrect. Antithetic variables have to be negatively correlated to the simulation variables in order to reduce the Monte Carlo sampling variability for a given number of replications, or to reduce the number of replications while retaining the current level of sampling variability.

B is incorrect. Both techniques can be used simultaneously, and the purpose of the two techniques is to reduce Monte Carlo sampling error – not bootstrapping error.

C is incorrect. In the first place, Monte Carlo simulation is evidently most useful when no analytical or closed-form solution exists – for example, when pricing complex exotic options. Hence, using control variates to reduce sampling error in Monte Carlo simulation would consequently be helpful in cases where no analytical solution exists.

老师,C和D 能否翻译一下?不明白C的closed form是啥意思,C为啥不对?

对偶变量是和抽取的变量相关系数相反的

那控制变量呢?

2 个答案
已采纳答案

李坏_品职助教 · 2024年11月10日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


a closed-form solution指的是对于一个问题有明确的解析解。比如BSM模型,就是通过BS微分方程求出来一个明确的解析公式。


但是对于其他问题,比如非常复杂的奇异期权,BSM模型失效,没有明确的解析解,用蒙特卡罗模拟的效果更好。


C说的是,在蒙特卡罗模拟法里面加入control variates仅限于有明确的解析解的情况,这个不对。蒙特卡罗反而是在没有解析解的情况下效果更好。

D说的是,在蒙特卡洛模拟里面应用control variates,可以让均值为0,并且把模拟值的相关系数设定为正数。为了提高蒙特卡罗模拟的效果,可以结合实际的市场环境对关键参数进行控制,让均值保持0,模拟变量的ρ>0是很常见的做法。

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版,加油!

梦梦 · 2024年11月10日

好的,您能再解释一下什么是对偶变量,什么是控制变量吗?

李坏_品职助教 · 2024年11月10日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


此处的control variates指的是,在模拟之前,我先对均值和相关系数进行条件限制,限制这些参数的取值范围。


而对偶变量法指的是,改变参数的数学形式,以使得参数估计的方差更小。比如:

可以看出,引入随机数U之后,总体的数学期望θ可以变换一种数学形式,而这个新的θ的参数估计的方差比上面独立抽样的参数估计方差更小了。

----------------------------------------------
加油吧,让我们一起遇见更好的自己!

梦梦 · 2024年11月11日

好的,谢谢

  • 2

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 58

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023091601000099 问题如下 A risk manager a hee funwants tocona simulation to forecast the stopriof a particulcompany afuture te. The manager aims to achieve this simulating the values of aEuropeoption anAsioption on the company’s stothmature on thespecifiefuture te, anconsirs severmetho to improve the accuraofthe simulation. Whiof the following statements is correregarng themetho typically useto resampling error? A.Antitheticvariables introa set of ranm variables thare positively correlateith the simulation variables to rethe number of replications. B.Control variatesanantithetic variables both rebootstrapping sampling variability for agiven number of replications. C.The use of controlvariates is limiteto simulations in whithere is a closeform solutionwith whito compare the simulateoutcome. The application ofcontrol variates involves employing a variable with a meof zero ana strongpositive correlation with the simulatevalues. is correct. This is the finition ofcontrol variates.A is incorrect. Antithetic variables have tonegatively correlateto the simulation variables in orr to retheMonte Carlo sampling variability for a given number of replications, or torethe number of replications while retaining the current level of samplingvariability. B is incorrect. Both techniques cuseimultaneously, anthe purpose of the two techniques is to reMonte Carlosampling error – not bootstrapping error. C is incorrect. In the first place, MonteCarlo simulation is evintly most useful when no analyticor closeformsolution exists – for example, when pricing complex exotic options. Hence,using control variates to resampling error in Monte Carlo simulation woulonsequently helpful in cases where no analyticsolution exists. 课件的P不太好搜索,请问一下这个是哪一章的知识点呢?

2024-11-04 06:15 1 · 回答