开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

黄路迦 · 2024年09月08日

贝叶斯

NO.PZ2018122801000006

问题如下:

In country X, the probability that a letter sent through the postal system reaches its destination is 2/3. Assume that each postal delivery is independent of every other postal delivery, and assume that if a wife receives a letter from her husband, she will certainly mail a response to her husband. Suppose a man in country X mails a letter to his wife (also in country X) through the postal system. If the man does not receive a response letter from his wife, what is the probability that his wife received his letter?

选项:

A.

1/3

B.

3/5

C.

2/3

D.

2/5

解释:

D is correct.

考点 Bayes' formula

解析

(Notices: if the wife did not receive the letter, she would not send response to the man.)

Note:

A: the wife received the letter; A ¯ : the wife did not receive the letter;

B: the man received a response letter from his wife; B ¯ : the man did not receive a response letter from his wife

The question "If the man does not receive a response letter from his wife, what is the probability that his wife received his letter?" is equal to figure out P(A| B ¯ )

考点:正态分布查表

P(A| B ¯ )= P(A B ¯ ) P( B ¯ ) = P( B ¯ )×P( B ¯ |A) P( B ¯ )×P( B ¯ |A)+P( B ¯ )×P( B ¯ | A ¯ ) 解析: 题目说信可以成功寄到的概率是2/3,假设每次送信都是独立事件。同时假设妻子如果收到丈夫的信就一定会回复。问题问如果丈夫没有收到回信,那她的妻子收到丈夫的信的概率是多少?

首先丈夫没有收到回信的条件有两种情况:1.丈夫的寄信丢了,就是上面那个二叉树的下面一根,概率是1/3;2.丈夫的信寄到了,但是妻子的回信寄丢了(1/3),这种情况下概率为1/3*(2/3)=2/9

所以这两种情况下概率加和=1/3+2/9=5/9

根据贝叶斯公式,

如果丈夫没有收到回信,那她的妻子收到丈夫的信的概率=(2/9)/(5/9)=2/5

= (2/3)×(1/3) (2/3)×(1/3)+(1/3)×1 = 2 5

为什么不是这样?不太明白

1 个答案

pzqa27 · 2024年09月09日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


按照您的算法,这个概率算下来是0,但是对于一个离散分布而言,如果丈夫没有收到回信,她的妻子是有可能收到丈夫的信。因此这里概率不应该是0.

这个算法主要问题在于回复和未回并不能直接赋值0和1,因为回复不回复之间的比例是2:1,并不是1:0.

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 105

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2018122801000006 问题如下 In country X, the probability tha letter sent through the postsystem reaches its stination is 2/3. Assume theapostlivery is inpennt of every other postlivery, anassume thif a wife receives a letter from her husban she will certainly mail a response to her husban Suppose a man in country X mails a letter to his wife (also in country X) through the postal system. If the mes not receive a response letter from his wife, whis the probability thhis wife receivehis letter? 1/3 3/5 2/3 2/5 is correct. 考点 Bayes' formul解析 (Notices: if the wife not receive the letter, she woulnot senresponse to the man.) Note: the wife receivethe letter; ¯ : the wife not receive the letter; the mreceivea response letter from his wife; ¯ : the mnot receive a response letter from his wife The question \"If the mes not receive a response letter from his wife, whis the probability thhis wife receivehis letter?\" is equto figure out P( ¯ ) 考点正态分布查表 P( ¯ )= P( ¯ ) P( ¯ ) = P( ¯ )×P( ¯ | P( ¯ )×P( ¯ |A)+P( ¯ )×P( ¯ | ¯ ) 解析 题目说信可以成功寄到的概率是2/3,假设每次送信都是独立事件。同时假设妻子如果收到丈夫的信就一定会回复。问题问如果丈夫没有收到回信,那她的妻子收到丈夫的信的概率是多少?首先丈夫没有收到回信的条件有两种情况1.丈夫的寄信丢了,就是上面那个二叉树的下面一根,概率是1/3;2.丈夫的信寄到了,但是妻子的回信寄丢了(1/3),这种情况下概率为1/3*(2/3)=2/9所以这两种情况下概率加和=1/3+2/9=5/9根据贝叶斯公式,如果丈夫没有收到回信,那她的妻子收到丈夫的信的概率=(2/9)/(5/9)=2/5 = (2/3)×(1/3) (2/3)×(1/3)+(1/3)×1 = 2 5 妻子回信的概率应该是100%信件能否送达的概率是2/3这两个不应该相等

2024-04-05 15:44 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018122801000006问题如下 In country X, the probability tha letter sent through the postsystem reaches its stination is 2/3. Assume theapostlivery is inpennt of every other postlivery, anassume thif a wife receives a letter from her husban she will certainly mail a response to her husban Suppose a man in country X mails a letter to his wife (also in country X) through the postal system. If the mes not receive a response letter from his wife, whis the probability thhis wife receivehis letter? 1/3 3/5 2/3 2/5 is correct. 考点 Bayes' formul解析 (Notices: if the wife not receive the letter, she woulnot senresponse to the man.) Note: the wife receivethe letter; ¯ : the wife not receive the letter; the mreceivea response letter from his wife; ¯ : the mnot receive a response letter from his wife The question \"If the mes not receive a response letter from his wife, whis the probability thhis wife receivehis letter?\" is equto figure out P( ¯ ) 考点正态分布查表 P( ¯ )= P( ¯ ) P( ¯ ) = P( ¯ )×P( ¯ | P( ¯ )×P( ¯ |A)+P( ¯ )×P( ¯ | ¯ ) 解析 题目说信可以成功寄到的概率是2/3,假设每次送信都是独立事件。同时假设妻子如果收到丈夫的信就一定会回复。问题问如果丈夫没有收到回信,那她的妻子收到丈夫的信的概率是多少?首先丈夫没有收到回信的条件有两种情况1.丈夫的寄信丢了,就是上面那个二叉树的下面一根,概率是1/3;2.丈夫的信寄到了,但是妻子的回信寄丢了(1/3),这种情况下概率为1/3*(2/3)=2/9所以这两种情况下概率加和=1/3+2/9=5/9根据贝叶斯公式,如果丈夫没有收到回信,那她的妻子收到丈夫的信的概率=(2/9)/(5/9)=2/5 = (2/3)×(1/3) (2/3)×(1/3)+(1/3)×1 = 2 5 老师我有两个问题第一个问题是,题目明明问的是,妻子收到丈夫的信,但丈夫没收到妻子的信,妻子只有收到丈夫的信才会回信,所以第二个树杈是不存在的。为什么不是2/3*1/3=2/9?见如下图第二个问题是左红框为什么等于右红框?课程里的贝叶斯公式只有分子的推导,没有分母的推导。

2024-01-31 21:14 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018122801000006 问题如下 In country X, the probability tha letter sent through the postsystem reaches its stination is 2/3. Assume theapostlivery is inpennt of every other postlivery, anassume thif a wife receives a letter from her husban she will certainly mail a response to her husban Suppose a man in country X mails a letter to his wife (also in country X) through the postal system. If the mes not receive a response letter from his wife, whis the probability thhis wife receivehis letter? 1/3 3/5 2/3 2/5 is correct. 考点 Bayes' formul解析 (Notices: if the wife not receive the letter, she woulnot senresponse to the man.) Note: the wife receivethe letter; ¯ : the wife not receive the letter; the mreceivea response letter from his wife; ¯ : the mnot receive a response letter from his wife The question \"If the mes not receive a response letter from his wife, whis the probability thhis wife receivehis letter?\" is equto figure out P( ¯ ) 考点正态分布查表 P( ¯ )= P( ¯ ) P( ¯ ) = P( ¯ )×P( ¯ | P( ¯ )×P( ¯ |A)+P( ¯ )×P( ¯ | ¯ ) 解析 题目说信可以成功寄到的概率是2/3,假设每次送信都是独立事件。同时假设妻子如果收到丈夫的信就一定会回复。问题问如果丈夫没有收到回信,那她的妻子收到丈夫的信的概率是多少?首先丈夫没有收到回信的条件有两种情况1.丈夫的寄信丢了,就是上面那个二叉树的下面一根,概率是1/3;2.丈夫的信寄到了,但是妻子的回信寄丢了(1/3),这种情况下概率为1/3*(2/3)=2/9所以这两种情况下概率加和=1/3+2/9=5/9根据贝叶斯公式,如果丈夫没有收到回信,那她的妻子收到丈夫的信的概率=(2/9)/(5/9)=2/5 = (2/3)×(1/3) (2/3)×(1/3)+(1/3)×1 = 2 5 为什么是beyes 公式,不是条件概率吗 P(A|B)

2024-01-30 16:47 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018122801000006 3/5 2/3 2/5 is correct. 考点 Bayes' formula 解析 (Notices: if the wife not receive the letter, she woulnot senresponse to the man.) Note: the wife receivethe letter; A ¯ : the wife not receive the letter; the mreceivea response letter from his wife; B ¯ : the mnot receive a response letter from his wife The question \"If the mes not receive a response letter from his wife, whis the probability thhis wife receivehis letter?\" is equto figure out P(B ¯ )   P(B ¯ )= P(A B ¯ ) P( B ¯ ) = P( B ¯ )×P( B ¯ |P( B ¯ )×P( B ¯ |A)+P( B ¯ )×P( B ¯ | A ¯ )   = (2/3)×(1/3) (2/3)×(1/3)+(1/3)×1 = 2 5   这里怎么是PAB等于PB*PB|A

2022-01-09 11:29 1 · 回答