开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

Cheung · 2024年08月04日

思考方向的疑惑

NO.PZ2022122601000015

问题如下:

Hadpret predicts an economic contraction and forecasts lower inflation and possibly deflation over the next 12 months. In response to the projected cyclical decline in the Eastland economy and in private sector borrowing over the next year, Hadpret expects a change in the monetary and fiscal policy mix. He forecasts that the Eastland central bank will ease monetary policy. On the fiscal side, Hadpret expects the Eastland government to enact a substantial tax cut. As a result, Hadpret forecasts large government deficits that will be financed by the issuance of long-term government securities.

Discuss the relationship between the shape of the yield curve and the monetary and fiscal policy mix projected by Hadpret.

选项:

解释:

Hadpret expects that, in response to a forecasted contraction in the Eastland economy, the central bank will ease monetary policy and the government will enact an expansionary fiscal policy. This policy mix has an impact on the shape of the yield curve.

The impact of changes in monetary policy on the yield curve are fairly clear, because changes in the yield curve’s slope—its flattening or steepening—are largely determined by the expected movement in short rates. This movement, in turn, is determined by the expected path of monetary policy and the state of the economy. With the central bank easing and the economy contracting, policy rates will be declining and will be expected to decline further as the central bank aims to counteract downward momentum in the economy. Bond yields also decline but by a lesser amount, so the yield curve steepens. The yield curve will typically continue to steepen during the contraction phase as the central bank continues to ease, reaching its steepest point just before the initial recovery phase.

Fiscal policy may affect the shape of the yield curve through the relative supply of bonds at various maturities that the government issues to fund deficits. Unlike the impact of monetary policy, the impact of changes in the supply of securities on the yield curve is unclear. The evidence seems to suggest that sufficiently large purchases/sales at different maturities will have only a temporary impact on yields. As a result, the large government budget deficits forecasted by Hadpret are unlikely to have much of a lasting impact on the yield curve, especially given that private sector borrowing will be falling during the contraction, somewhat offsetting the increase in the supply of government securities.

中文解析:

哈普雷特预计,为了应对东部地区经济的预期收缩,央行将放松货币政策,政府将制定扩张性财政政策。这种政策组合对收益率曲线的形状有影响。

货币政策变化对收益率曲线的影响相当明显,因为收益率曲线斜率的变化——趋平或趋陡——很大程度上取决于短期利率的预期变动。反过来,这种走势是由货币政策的预期路径和经济状况决定的。随着央行的宽松政策和经济的收缩,政策利率将会下降,而且预计会进一步下降,因为央行的目标是抵消经济的下行势头。债券收益率也会下降,但下降幅度较小,因此收益率曲线变陡。在收缩阶段,随着央行继续放松货币政策,收益率曲线通常会继续变陡,在最初的复苏阶段之前达到最陡的点。

财政政策可以通过政府为填补赤字而发行的不同期限债券的相对供应量来影响收益率曲线的形状。与货币政策的影响不同,证券供应变化对收益率曲线的影响尚不清楚。证据似乎表明,不同期限的足够大的购买/出售只会对收益率产生暂时的影响。因此,哈普雷特预测的巨额政府预算赤字不太可能对收益率曲线产生太大的持久影响,特别是考虑到私营部门的借款将在收缩期间下降,这在一定程度上抵消了政府证券供应的增加。

为什么不能认为是宽松的货币政策和宽松的财政政策同时实行,则interest rate上升?为什么这道题不能从这个角度思考?

1 个答案
已采纳答案

源_品职助教 · 2024年08月05日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


 CME的教材,的确有过结论:

宽松的财政政策影响真实利率。宽松的货币政策影响通胀,这两点是可以决定一个平均的利率水平。

但是本题问的是对收益率曲线形状的影响。收益率曲线取决于短期利率和长期利率大小关系,也就是要分析短期和长期(债券)利率

那 宽松的财政政策影响真实利率。宽松的货币政策影响通胀 。这和短期利率长期利率就对应不上啊。

所以还是要按照题目的思路来记忆以下答题思路。   


----------------------------------------------
加油吧,让我们一起遇见更好的自己!

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 117

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2022122601000015 问题如下 Haret prects economic contraction anforecasts lowerinflation anpossibly flation over the next 12 months. In response to theprojectecycliccline in the Eastlaneconomy anin private sectorborrowing over the next year, Haret expects a change in the monetary aniscpolimix. He forecasts ththe Eastlancentrbank will easemonetary policy. On the fiscsi, Haret expects the Eastlangovernment toenaa substantitcut. a result, Haret forecasts large government ficitsthwill financethe issuanof long-term government securities.scuss the relationshipbetween the shape of the yielcurve anthe monetary anfiscpolimixprojecteHaret. Haret expectsthat, in response to a forecastecontraction in the Eastlaneconomy, thecentrbank will ease monetary polianthe government will enaanexpansionary fiscpolicy. This polimix himpaon the shape of theyielcurve.The impaofchanges in monetary polion the yielcurve are fairly clear, because changesin the yielcurve’s slope—its flattening or steepening—are largely terminey the expectemovement in short rates. This movement, in turn, is terminey the expectepath of monetary polianthe state of the economy. With thecentrbank easing anthe economy contracting, polirates will clininganwill expecteto cline further the centrbank aims to counteractwnwarmomentum in the economy. Bonyiel also cline but a lesseramount, so the yielcurve steepens. The yielcurve will typically continue tosteepen ring the contraction phase the centrbank continues to ease,reaching its steepest point just before the initirecovery phase.Fiscpolicymaffethe shape of the yielcurve through the relative supply of bon atvarious maturities ththe government issues to funficits. Unlike theimpaof monetary policy, the impaof changes in the supply of securities onthe yielcurve is unclear. The evinseems to suggest thsufficientlylarge purchases/sales fferent maturities will have only a temporary impacton yiel. a result, the large government buet ficits forecastebyHaret are unlikely to have muof a lasting impaon the yielcurve,especially given thprivate sector borrowing will falling ring thecontraction, somewhoffsetting the increase in the supply of governmentsecurities.中文解析 哈普雷特预计,为了应对东部地区经济的预期收缩,央行将放松货币政策,政府将制定扩张性财政政策。这种政策组合对收益率曲线的形状有影响。货币政策变化对收益率曲线的影响相当明显,因为收益率曲线斜率的变化——趋平或趋陡——很大程度上取决于短期利率的预期变动。反过来,这种走势是由货币政策的预期路径和经济状况决定的。随着央行的宽松政策和经济的收缩,政策利率将会下降,而且预计会进一步下降,因为央行的目标是抵消经济的下行势头。债券收益率也会下降,但下降幅度较小,因此收益率曲线变陡。在收缩阶段,随着央行继续放松货币政策,收益率曲线通常会继续变陡,在最初的复苏阶段之前达到最陡的点。财政政策可以通过政府为填补赤字而发行的不同期限债券的相对供应量来影响收益率曲线的形状。与货币政策的影响不同,证券供应变化对收益率曲线的影响尚不清楚。证据似乎表明,不同期限的足够大的购买/出售只会对收益率产生暂时的影响。因此,哈普雷特预测的巨额政府预算赤字不太可能对收益率曲线产生太大的持久影响,特别是考虑到私营部门的借款将在收缩期间下降,这在一定程度上抵消了政府证券供应的增加。 我记得课上老师讲过这种思路,就是发行大量政府长期债券,那么市场上价格就会降低,说明长期利率会增加。在答案中这么写可不可以?

2024-08-10 21:14 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022122601000015问题如下 Haret prects economic contraction anforecasts lowerinflation anpossibly flation over the next 12 months. In response to theprojectecycliccline in the Eastlaneconomy anin private sectorborrowing over the next year, Haret expects a change in the monetary aniscpolimix. He forecasts ththe Eastlancentrbank will easemonetary policy. On the fiscsi, Haret expects the Eastlangovernment toenaa substantitcut. a result, Haret forecasts large government ficitsthwill financethe issuanof long-term government securities.scuss the relationshipbetween the shape of the yielcurve anthe monetary anfiscpolimixprojecteHaret. Haret expectsthat, in response to a forecastecontraction in the Eastlaneconomy, thecentrbank will ease monetary polianthe government will enaanexpansionary fiscpolicy. This polimix himpaon the shape of theyielcurve.The impaofchanges in monetary polion the yielcurve are fairly clear, because changesin the yielcurve’s slope—its flattening or steepening—are largely terminey the expectemovement in short rates. This movement, in turn, is terminey the expectepath of monetary polianthe state of the economy. With thecentrbank easing anthe economy contracting, polirates will clininganwill expecteto cline further the centrbank aims to counteractwnwarmomentum in the economy. Bonyiel also cline but a lesseramount, so the yielcurve steepens. The yielcurve will typically continue tosteepen ring the contraction phase the centrbank continues to ease,reaching its steepest point just before the initirecovery phase.Fiscpolicymaffethe shape of the yielcurve through the relative supply of bon atvarious maturities ththe government issues to funficits. Unlike theimpaof monetary policy, the impaof changes in the supply of securities onthe yielcurve is unclear. The evinseems to suggest thsufficientlylarge purchases/sales fferent maturities will have only a temporary impacton yiel. a result, the large government buet ficits forecastebyHaret are unlikely to have muof a lasting impaon the yielcurve,especially given thprivate sector borrowing will falling ring thecontraction, somewhoffsetting the increase in the supply of governmentsecurities.中文解析 哈普雷特预计,为了应对东部地区经济的预期收缩,央行将放松货币政策,政府将制定扩张性财政政策。这种政策组合对收益率曲线的形状有影响。货币政策变化对收益率曲线的影响相当明显,因为收益率曲线斜率的变化——趋平或趋陡——很大程度上取决于短期利率的预期变动。反过来,这种走势是由货币政策的预期路径和经济状况决定的。随着央行的宽松政策和经济的收缩,政策利率将会下降,而且预计会进一步下降,因为央行的目标是抵消经济的下行势头。债券收益率也会下降,但下降幅度较小,因此收益率曲线变陡。在收缩阶段,随着央行继续放松货币政策,收益率曲线通常会继续变陡,在最初的复苏阶段之前达到最陡的点。财政政策可以通过政府为填补赤字而发行的不同期限债券的相对供应量来影响收益率曲线的形状。与货币政策的影响不同,证券供应变化对收益率曲线的影响尚不清楚。证据似乎表明,不同期限的足够大的购买/出售只会对收益率产生暂时的影响。因此,哈普雷特预测的巨额政府预算赤字不太可能对收益率曲线产生太大的持久影响,特别是考虑到私营部门的借款将在收缩期间下降,这在一定程度上抵消了政府证券供应的增加。 我是这样考虑的The long term rate is moving wnwaraffectethe low inflation expectation; the same time, because of the loose fiscpoliof recing tax, it gives a upwarpotentifor the long term rate whioffset the wnwarmovement from inflation expectation. Combinethis consiration on fiscpolicy, the curve will steepen in short run anflatten in long run.

2024-06-30 21:21 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022122601000015 问题如下 Haret prects economic contraction anforecasts lowerinflation anpossibly flation over the next 12 months. In response to theprojectecycliccline in the Eastlaneconomy anin private sectorborrowing over the next year, Haret expects a change in the monetary aniscpolimix. He forecasts ththe Eastlancentrbank will easemonetary policy. On the fiscsi, Haret expects the Eastlangovernment toenaa substantitcut. a result, Haret forecasts large government ficitsthwill financethe issuanof long-term government securities.scuss the relationshipbetween the shape of the yielcurve anthe monetary anfiscpolimixprojecteHaret. Haret expectsthat, in response to a forecastecontraction in the Eastlaneconomy, thecentrbank will ease monetary polianthe government will enaanexpansionary fiscpolicy. This polimix himpaon the shape of theyielcurve.The impaofchanges in monetary polion the yielcurve are fairly clear, because changesin the yielcurve’s slope—its flattening or steepening—are largely terminey the expectemovement in short rates. This movement, in turn, is terminey the expectepath of monetary polianthe state of the economy. With thecentrbank easing anthe economy contracting, polirates will clininganwill expecteto cline further the centrbank aims to counteractwnwarmomentum in the economy. Bonyiel also cline but a lesseramount, so the yielcurve steepens. The yielcurve will typically continue tosteepen ring the contraction phase the centrbank continues to ease,reaching its steepest point just before the initirecovery phase.Fiscpolicymaffethe shape of the yielcurve through the relative supply of bon atvarious maturities ththe government issues to funficits. Unlike theimpaof monetary policy, the impaof changes in the supply of securities onthe yielcurve is unclear. The evinseems to suggest thsufficientlylarge purchases/sales fferent maturities will have only a temporary impacton yiel. a result, the large government buet ficits forecastebyHaret are unlikely to have muof a lasting impaon the yielcurve,especially given thprivate sector borrowing will falling ring thecontraction, somewhoffsetting the increase in the supply of governmentsecurities.中文解析 哈普雷特预计,为了应对东部地区经济的预期收缩,央行将放松货币政策,政府将制定扩张性财政政策。这种政策组合对收益率曲线的形状有影响。货币政策变化对收益率曲线的影响相当明显,因为收益率曲线斜率的变化——趋平或趋陡——很大程度上取决于短期利率的预期变动。反过来,这种走势是由货币政策的预期路径和经济状况决定的。随着央行的宽松政策和经济的收缩,政策利率将会下降,而且预计会进一步下降,因为央行的目标是抵消经济的下行势头。债券收益率也会下降,但下降幅度较小,因此收益率曲线变陡。在收缩阶段,随着央行继续放松货币政策,收益率曲线通常会继续变陡,在最初的复苏阶段之前达到最陡的点。财政政策可以通过政府为填补赤字而发行的不同期限债券的相对供应量来影响收益率曲线的形状。与货币政策的影响不同,证券供应变化对收益率曲线的影响尚不清楚。证据似乎表明,不同期限的足够大的购买/出售只会对收益率产生暂时的影响。因此,哈普雷特预测的巨额政府预算赤字不太可能对收益率曲线产生太大的持久影响,特别是考虑到私营部门的借款将在收缩期间下降,这在一定程度上抵消了政府证券供应的增加。 如果在考试中遇见这道题,这样答会得分吗?针对题目里的情况直接写yielcurve形状的变化,不详细说现实情况The yielcurve will steepenunr the monetary anfiscpolimix projecteHaret. -The expansive monetary poliwill move the short term rate wnwar-To enaa substantitcut is also a expansive phsicpolicy, whiwill move the long term rate upwar.-If the economy is currently in the late expansion phase with inverteyielcurve, the yielcurve will invert baupwarsloping; if the economy is alrea in the contraction phase right now with a alrea upwarsloping, the yielcurve will steeper over the next year.

2024-06-09 00:54 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2022122601000015问题如下 Haret prects economic contraction anforecasts lowerinflation anpossibly flation over the next 12 months. In response to theprojectecycliccline in the Eastlaneconomy anin private sectorborrowing over the next year, Haret expects a change in the monetary aniscpolimix. He forecasts ththe Eastlancentrbank will easemonetary policy. On the fiscsi, Haret expects the Eastlangovernment toenaa substantitcut. a result, Haret forecasts large government ficitsthwill financethe issuanof long-term government securities.scuss the relationshipbetween the shape of the yielcurve anthe monetary anfiscpolimixprojecteHaret. Haret expectsthat, in response to a forecastecontraction in the Eastlaneconomy, thecentrbank will ease monetary polianthe government will enaanexpansionary fiscpolicy. This polimix himpaon the shape of theyielcurve.The impaofchanges in monetary polion the yielcurve are fairly clear, because changesin the yielcurve’s slope—its flattening or steepening—are largely terminey the expectemovement in short rates. This movement, in turn, is terminey the expectepath of monetary polianthe state of the economy. With thecentrbank easing anthe economy contracting, polirates will clininganwill expecteto cline further the centrbank aims to counteractwnwarmomentum in the economy. Bonyiel also cline but a lesseramount, so the yielcurve steepens. The yielcurve will typically continue tosteepen ring the contraction phase the centrbank continues to ease,reaching its steepest point just before the initirecovery phase.Fiscpolicymaffethe shape of the yielcurve through the relative supply of bon atvarious maturities ththe government issues to funficits. Unlike theimpaof monetary policy, the impaof changes in the supply of securities onthe yielcurve is unclear. The evinseems to suggest thsufficientlylarge purchases/sales fferent maturities will have only a temporary impacton yiel. a result, the large government buet ficits forecastebyHaret are unlikely to have muof a lasting impaon the yielcurve,especially given thprivate sector borrowing will falling ring thecontraction, somewhoffsetting the increase in the supply of governmentsecurities.中文解析 哈普雷特预计,为了应对东部地区经济的预期收缩,央行将放松货币政策,政府将制定扩张性财政政策。这种政策组合对收益率曲线的形状有影响。货币政策变化对收益率曲线的影响相当明显,因为收益率曲线斜率的变化——趋平或趋陡——很大程度上取决于短期利率的预期变动。反过来,这种走势是由货币政策的预期路径和经济状况决定的。随着央行的宽松政策和经济的收缩,政策利率将会下降,而且预计会进一步下降,因为央行的目标是抵消经济的下行势头。债券收益率也会下降,但下降幅度较小,因此收益率曲线变陡。在收缩阶段,随着央行继续放松货币政策,收益率曲线通常会继续变陡,在最初的复苏阶段之前达到最陡的点。财政政策可以通过政府为填补赤字而发行的不同期限债券的相对供应量来影响收益率曲线的形状。与货币政策的影响不同,证券供应变化对收益率曲线的影响尚不清楚。证据似乎表明,不同期限的足够大的购买/出售只会对收益率产生暂时的影响。因此,哈普雷特预测的巨额政府预算赤字不太可能对收益率曲线产生太大的持久影响,特别是考虑到私营部门的借款将在收缩期间下降,这在一定程度上抵消了政府证券供应的增加。 On the fiscsi, Haret expects the Eastlangovernment to enaa substantitcut. 宽松的财政政策会提高融资需求,从而提升实际利率,但是在这里体现为长期收益率下降,应该如何理解这个区别呢?

2023-11-18 11:41 1 · 回答