开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

约克羊 · 2024年07月29日

对realize ST gains 的疑问

NO.PZ2023032703000016

问题如下:

Derran thanks Shield and Edge for their counsel. She decides that she would like to alter the portfolio by reducing the allocation to equity securities and adding exposure to both inflation-protected notes and corporate bonds. Because she will be paying capital gains taxes on the sale of the equity securities, she wishes to minimize future investment-related taxes. Derran makes the following comment: “My priority is for the annual donation to the PLU endowment to be funded from interest income and maturing bonds. At times, we may need to swap similar bonds for tax management purposes. Unless you are offsetting gains with losses, you should realize short-term gains while deferring short-term losses because I consider myself to be a patient investor.”

Is Derran’s comment most likely correct as it relates to tax loss harvesting? (2019 mock AM)

选项:

A.

No. She is incorrect about short-term gains and short-term losses.

B.

Yes

C.

No. She is incorrect about offsetting gains with losses.

解释:

A is correct. Derran’s comment about realizing short-term gains while deferring short-term losses is not correct in the context of tax loss harvesting. Tax loss harvesting involves the timing of investment sales and thus the realization of gains and losses. Controlling the timing of realizing gains and losses can be valuable for a taxable investor because it may be optimal to delay realizing gains and related tax payments and to realize losses as soon as possible. Among the important considerations of tax loss harvesting is a comparison of short-term and long-term capital gains rates.

C is incorrect. Derran’s comment about offsetting gains with losses is correct in the context of tax loss harvesting.

税的基础知识我是理解的,但是实现ST gain这里 前面用的不是unless, 那么安安不是应该取反,也就是说都是对的吗。还能把条件状语从句来分开判断呀?

1 个答案
已采纳答案

发亮_品职助教 · 2024年07月29日

这道题是早几年的一道Mock题,质量不是很高哈,所以这道题的表述比较别扭。


Unless you are offsetting gains with losses, you should realize short-term gains while deferring short-term losses because I consider myself to be a patient investor


这句话意思是,除非我们是用losses来抵消gains(抵税),否则在一般情况下(不考虑抵税的情况下),我们应该realized short-term gains,同时递延short-term losses。


其实,在不考虑抵税的情况下,要不要实现short-term gains,取决于投资者对未来投资的预期,如果预期有更大的long-term capital gain,那肯定不会提前实现short-term gains;同理,要不要递延short-term losses,也要看投资者对未来的预期。不一定非得递延,如果这项投资根据预期判断要underweight,那就是要直接卖出实现short-term losses,所以这句话的问题是说的太过绝对了。


应该说在投资中,是否要实现capital gain or capital loss,第一个考虑因素是对未来投资收益的预期,然后才考虑抵税的问题。不能说为了抵税,而直接不考虑资产的预期。

约克羊 · 2024年07月29日

回答一语中的,强!

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 90

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023032703000016 问题如下 rrthanks ShielanEe for their counsel. She cis thshe woullike to alter the portfolio recing the allocation to equity securities anaing exposure to both inflation-protectenotes ancorporate bon. Because she will paying capitgains taxes on the sale of the equity securities, she wishes to minimize future investment-relatetaxes. rrmakes the following comment: “My priority is for the annunation to the PLU enwment to funfrom interest income anmaturing bon. times, we mneeto swsimilbon for tmanagement purposes. Unless you are offsetting gains with losses, you shoulrealize short-term gains while ferring short-term losses because I consir myself to a patient investor.”Is rran’s comment most likely correit relates to tloss harvesting? (2019 moAM) A.No. She is incorreabout short-term gains anshort-term losses. B.Yes C.No. She is incorreabout offsetting gains with losses. A is correct. rran’s comment about realizing short-term gains while ferring short-term losses is not correin the context of tloss harvesting. Tloss harvesting involves the timing of investment sales anthus the realization of gains anlosses. Controlling the timing of realizing gains anlosses cvaluable for a taxable investor because it moptimto lrealizing gains anrelatetpayments anto realize losses soon possible. Among the important consirations of tloss harvesting is a comparison of short-term anlong-term capitgains rates.C is incorrect. rran’s comment about offsetting gains with losses is correin the context of tloss harvesting. 请问如果题目中不写主人公想减少tax,他是要给enwment nate,那这笔钱是不是就是tax-exempt的?

2024-07-09 10:11 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2023032703000016问题如下 rrthanks ShielanEe for their counsel. She cis thshe woullike to alter the portfolio recing the allocation to equity securities anaing exposure to both inflation-protectenotes ancorporate bon. Because she will paying capitgains taxes on the sale of the equity securities, she wishes to minimize future investment-relatetaxes. rrmakes the following comment: “My priority is for the annunation to the PLU enwment to funfrom interest income anmaturing bon. times, we mneeto swsimilbon for tmanagement purposes. Unless you are offsetting gains with losses, you shoulrealize short-term gains while ferring short-term losses because I consir myself to a patient investor.”Is rran’s comment most likely correit relates to tloss harvesting? (2019 moAM) A.No. She is incorreabout short-term gains anshort-term losses.B.YesC.No. She is incorreabout offsetting gains with losses. A is correct. rran’s comment about realizing short-term gains while ferring short-term losses is not correin the context of tloss harvesting. Tloss harvesting involves the timing of investment sales anthus the realization of gains anlosses. Controlling the timing of realizing gains anlosses cvaluable for a taxable investor because it moptimto lrealizing gains anrelatetpayments anto realize losses soon possible. Among the important consirations of tloss harvesting is a comparison of short-term anlong-term capitgains rates.C is incorrect. rran’s comment about offsetting gains with losses is correin the context of tloss harvesting. 为什么对loss要realize soon possible

2024-07-09 09:25 1 · 回答