NO.PZ2022120703000024
问题如下：
For an energy company, Scope 1 emissions most likely result from:
选项：
A.purchasing freight services.
B.using the company's vehicles.
C.disposing of waste at the company's gas stations.
解释：
B is correct because, for an energy company, the emissions generated from driving and using the company's vehicles are Scope 1 emissions as they are under the direct control of the company.According to GHG Protocol Standards, emissions related to company vehicles are Scope 1 emissions."While Scopes 1 and 2 cover direct emissions sources (such as the fuel used in company vehicles and purchased electricity), Scope 3 emissions cover all indirect emissions arising from the activities of an organisation."
A is incorrect because emissions arising from purchasing freight services are Scope 3 emissions for an energy company. An energy company relies on various services produced by third parties. These third parties generate GHG in their production and operating processes and these are Scope 1 GHG for the third parties. At the same time, they represent Scope 3 emissions for the energy company.
C is incorrect because emissions arising from waste disposal processes are Scope 3 emissions for an energy company. Managing waste disposal is not an energy company's main business, nor is waste used in its operations. Thus emissions from waste disposal represent Scope 3 emissions and are not under the company's direct control.
如果按照之前对这道题的解释，说C选项不知道是自己公司还是其他公司处理的，我是不是也可以对B选项这样理解：公司使用的车是油车还是电车？电车的话是不是属于公司用电，那就是范围2了呀？而对于C来说，公司的gas station来处理这些垃圾，那这个gas不也属于燃料嘛？等于是公司直接使用燃料了呀！此外，如果按照另一个之前的解释说说公司的主营业务不是处理垃圾所以不选C，那还有题说公司厨房做饭的碳排放属于范围一，可是公司的主营业务也不是做饭呀！所以我觉得这个题还是有歧义，难以理解
