开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

明明要加油 · 2023年10月04日

我算出来S0=15.44， 之后就不会了，这是用到了老师讲的哪个知识点呢？

  1. CFA II
  2. Derivative

NO.PZ2023020101000023

问题如下：

Cummins states that long-/short-hedge fund managers seek to identify and exploit any mispricing that may exist between the price of an option and the price of its underlying stock, utilizing a replicating strategy. Cummins asks Spelding to assess the three scenarios outlined in Exhibit 2, based on the information in Exhibit 1 and assuming that the price of a one-year European-style call option is $19.25.

Exhibit 1: Binomial Model Variables and Values

Exhibit 2: Scenarios and Replicating Strategies

With respect to the replicating strategies, which scenario is most likely correct:

选项：

A.

Scenario 1.

B.

Scenario 2.

C.

Scenario 3.

解释：

The $19.25 price of the call option exceeds its value of $15.44, as calculated based on both the no-arbitrage approach and the expectations approach. Accordingly, the replicating strategy per 100 shares is to (1) sell 1 option, (2) buy h shares, and (3) borrow h * (up/down factor price + up/down call payoff).

The call option calculations follow:

• No-arbitrage approach:

Hedge ratio

h=c+−c−S+−S−=35−0135−75=3560=0.5833h=\frac{c^+-c^-}{S^+-S^-}=\frac{35-0}{135-75}=\frac{35}{60}=0.5833

Call Option value

c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+(−75∗0.5833)1.02+0=$15.44c=hS+PV(-hS^-+c^-=0.5833\ast100+\frac{{(-75\ast0}{.5833)}}{1.02}+0=\$15.44

• Expectations approach:

Probability of an up move π=0.45

Call Option value

c=35∗0.45+01+0.2=$15.44c=\frac{35\ast0.45+0}{1+0.2}=\$15.44

我看了之前老师回答的答案，

【根据无套利组合，每卖出1份call，需要long Δ份股票，因此我们long0.58份股票】

无套利组合是啥，这是李老师在哪里讲的知识点？



为什么不能用C+K=P+S？我最开始尝试用这个思考，发现算不出来。


我也用了老师讲的等式，如下图，推出的是卖出看涨期权【也就是题目所求的操作内容】，等于买空股票加买入债券，发现答案没有我的这个选项。请老师指出我错在哪里呢？




添加评论
3 个答案
已采纳答案

李坏_品职助教 · 2023年10月04日

嗨，从没放弃的小努力你好：


无套利组合方法（参考基础班讲义P101，这个章节是Valuing Stock Option with Binomial Model）指的是：

就是利用股票和融资来复制一个看涨期权。用到的股票数量就是前面算出来的h，也就是Hedge Ratio。

h = 0.58意思就是，我们可以用0.58个股票+PV(-hS- + C-)这么多的融资来复制1个call option。


这么想：call optoin是赋予期权买方一个在未来行使权力买入股票的机会，也就是说股票越涨，call option越值钱。所以要复制call option肯定是要手里有股票。而套利的本质是尽可能使用借来的钱去买资产，所以要用PV(-hS- + C-)这么多的现金（borrow来的现金）去买股票。

所以理论上：buy stock + borrow 现金 = call option。


由于计算出来的call option的报价19.25远大于它的理论价值15.44，所以为了进行套利，应该高价卖出call option，同时利用buy stock + borrow 现金复制一个15.44的低成本option，这样就实现了套利。

----------------------------------------------
加油吧，让我们一起遇见更好的自己！

明明要加油 · 2023年10月04日

老师，您看我最开始写在图里面的公式，因为期权的价值远低于市场价格，当前期权被over valued。所以套利的时候，低买高卖，就是卖出期权获得市场价格19.25，再买入一个组合。 我在等式左右两边加了负号，左边是short call option，等于右边是short H份股票并且long bond。和答案不一样，我不知道自己错在哪里？为什么用这个等式思考不行？

李坏_品职助教 · 2023年10月04日

嗨，努力学习的PZer你好：


对的，你理解的正确。

----------------------------------------------
加油吧，让我们一起遇见更好的自己！

李坏_品职助教 · 2023年10月04日

嗨，从没放弃的小努力你好：


一个call option的多头 = 买入h份股票+borrow现金。


你一开始已经高价卖出一个call option，等于是call option的空头，那么为了构造套利组合，必须用股票和现金来复制call option的多头来实现“低买”的操作，这样才是完整的低买、高卖，才能实现套利。


你直接对等式取符号，那是两边都做空，没法套利了。

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来，我们正在朝着它而去，加油！

明明要加油 · 2023年10月04日

哦，我在等式两边同时加负号，相当于short call 可以用什么来复制对吧？ 即：short call（卖出看涨期权）等于卖出股票，买入债券（投资债券）。 实际这道题，应该是一正一负，最终手里头寸为0 ，才是套利的本质喽

  • 3

    回答

  • 3

    关注

  • 294

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023020101000023 问题如下 Cummins states thlong-/short-hee funanagers seek to intify anexploit any mispricing thmexist between thepriof option anthe priof its unrlying stock, utilizing areplicating strategy. Cummins asks Spelng to assess the three scenariosoutlinein Exhibit 2, baseon the information in Exhibit 1 anassuming thatthe priof a one-yeEuropean-style call option is $19.25.Exhibit1: BinomiMol Variables anValuesExhibit2: Scenarios anReplicating StrategiesWith respeto the replicatingstrategies, whiscenario is mostlikely correct: A.Scenario1. B.Scenario2. C.Scenario3. The$19.25 priof the call option excee its value of $15.44, calculateaseon both the no-arbitrage approaanthe expectations approach.Accorngly, the replicating strategy per 100 shares is to (1) sell 1 option, (2)buy h shares, an(3) borrow h * (up/wn factor pri+ up/wn call payoff).Thecall option calculations follow:• No-arbitrage approach:Hee ratio h=c+−c−S+−S−=35−0135−75=3560=0.5833h=\frac{c^+-c^-}{S^+-S^-}=\frac{35-0}{135-75}=\frac{35}{60}=0.5833h=S+−S−c+−c−​=135−7535−0​=6035​=0.5833Call Option value c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+(−75∗0.5833)1.02+0=$15.44c=hS+PV(-hS^-+c^-=0.5833\ast100+\frac{{(-75\ast0}{.5833)}}{1.02}+0=\$15.44c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+1.02(−75∗0.5833)​+0=$15.44 • Expectations approach:Probability of up move π=0.45 Call Option valuec=35∗0.45+01+0.02=$15.44c=\frac{35\ast0.45+0}{1+0.02}=\$15.44c=1+0.0235∗0.45+0​=$15.44 如果说long call=long stock+卖bon钱，那现在需要short call为什么仍然是buy stock，而不是short呢

2024-09-05 22:02 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2023020101000023 问题如下 Cummins states thlong-/short-hee funanagers seek to intify anexploit any mispricing thmexist between thepriof option anthe priof its unrlying stock, utilizing areplicating strategy. Cummins asks Spelng to assess the three scenariosoutlinein Exhibit 2, baseon the information in Exhibit 1 anassuming thatthe priof a one-yeEuropean-style call option is $19.25.Exhibit1: BinomiMol Variables anValuesExhibit2: Scenarios anReplicating StrategiesWith respeto the replicatingstrategies, whiscenario is mostlikely correct: A.Scenario1. B.Scenario2. C.Scenario3. The$19.25 priof the call option excee its value of $15.44, calculateaseon both the no-arbitrage approaanthe expectations approach.Accorngly, the replicating strategy per 100 shares is to (1) sell 1 option, (2)buy h shares, an(3) borrow h * (up/wn factor pri+ up/wn call payoff).Thecall option calculations follow:• No-arbitrage approach:Hee ratio h=c+−c−S+−S−=35−0135−75=3560=0.5833h=\frac{c^+-c^-}{S^+-S^-}=\frac{35-0}{135-75}=\frac{35}{60}=0.5833h=S+−S−c+−c−​=135−7535−0​=6035​=0.5833Call Option value c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+(−75∗0.5833)1.02+0=$15.44c=hS+PV(-hS^-+c^-=0.5833\ast100+\frac{{(-75\ast0}{.5833)}}{1.02}+0=\$15.44c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+1.02(−75∗0.5833)​+0=$15.44 • Expectations approach:Probability of up move π=0.45 Call Option valuec=35∗0.45+01+0.2=$15.44c=\frac{35\ast0.45+0}{1+0.2}=\$15.44c=1+0.235∗0.45+0​=$15.44 C=hS0- PV(bonIf we are buying synethic call, isn't it buy h shares of stoanshort bonwhiis lenmoney.I having a hartime unrstanng the the + an- sign of the PV term.

2023-10-14 02:05 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2023020101000023 问题如下 Cummins states thlong-/short-hee funanagers seek to intify anexploit any mispricing thmexist between thepriof option anthe priof its unrlying stock, utilizing areplicating strategy. Cummins asks Spelng to assess the three scenariosoutlinein Exhibit 2, baseon the information in Exhibit 1 anassuming thatthe priof a one-yeEuropean-style call option is $19.25.Exhibit1: BinomiMol Variables anValuesExhibit2: Scenarios anReplicating StrategiesWith respeto the replicatingstrategies, whiscenario is mostlikely correct: A.Scenario1. B.Scenario2. C.Scenario3. The$19.25 priof the call option excee its value of $15.44, calculateaseon both the no-arbitrage approaanthe expectations approach.Accorngly, the replicating strategy per 100 shares is to (1) sell 1 option, (2)buy h shares, an(3) borrow h * (up/wn factor pri+ up/wn call payoff).Thecall option calculations follow:• No-arbitrage approach:Hee ratio h=c+−c−S+−S−=35−0135−75=3560=0.5833h=\frac{c^+-c^-}{S^+-S^-}=\frac{35-0}{135-75}=\frac{35}{60}=0.5833h=S+−S−c+−c−​=135−7535−0​=6035​=0.5833Call Option value c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+(−75∗0.5833)1.02+0=$15.44c=hS+PV(-hS^-+c^-=0.5833\ast100+\frac{{(-75\ast0}{.5833)}}{1.02}+0=\$15.44c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+1.02(−75∗0.5833)​+0=$15.44 • Expectations approach:Probability of up move π=0.45 Call Option valuec=35∗0.45+01+0.2=$15.44c=\frac{35\ast0.45+0}{1+0.2}=\$15.44c=1+0.235∗0.45+0​=$15.44 老师，1）options tra / stotra/ Financing 分别是什么？2）如何做这个套利？

2023-08-30 20:55 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2023020101000023 问题如下 Cummins states thlong-/short-hee funanagers seek to intify anexploit any mispricing thmexist between thepriof option anthe priof its unrlying stock, utilizing areplicating strategy. Cummins asks Spelng to assess the three scenariosoutlinein Exhibit 2, baseon the information in Exhibit 1 anassuming thatthe priof a one-yeEuropean-style call option is $19.25.Exhibit1: BinomiMol Variables anValuesExhibit2: Scenarios anReplicating StrategiesWith respeto the replicatingstrategies, whiscenario is mostlikely correct: A.Scenario1. B.Scenario2. C.Scenario3. The$19.25 priof the call option excee its value of $15.44, calculateaseon both the no-arbitrage approaanthe expectations approach.Accorngly, the replicating strategy per 100 shares is to (1) sell 1 option, (2)buy h shares, an(3) borrow h * (up/wn factor pri+ up/wn call payoff).Thecall option calculations follow:• No-arbitrage approach:Hee ratio h=c+−c−S+−S−=35−0135−75=3560=0.5833h=\frac{c^+-c^-}{S^+-S^-}=\frac{35-0}{135-75}=\frac{35}{60}=0.5833h=S+−S−c+−c−​=135−7535−0​=6035​=0.5833Call Option value c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+(−75∗0.5833)1.02+0=$15.44c=hS+PV(-hS^-+c^-=0.5833\ast100+\frac{{(-75\ast0}{.5833)}}{1.02}+0=\$15.44c=hS+PV(−hS−+c−=0.5833∗100+1.02(−75∗0.5833)​+0=$15.44 • Expectations approach:Probability of up move π=0.45 Call Option valuec=35∗0.45+01+0.2=$15.44c=\frac{35\ast0.45+0}{1+0.2}=\$15.44c=1+0.235∗0.45+0​=$15.44 Accorngly, the replicating strategy per 100 shares is to (1) sell 1 option, (2) buy h shares, an(3) borrow h * (up/wn factor pri+ up/wn call payoff).算出来的15,44我懂，怎么操作我没理解

2023-07-09 16:09 2 · 回答