开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

sincex · 2023年07月14日

这道题答案只需要陈述现象吗?

NO.PZ2023012803000001

问题如下:

At their initial meeting, the advisor learns that Stoffer is a mid-level manager at a bank and has built an investment portfolio by accumulating savings, stock options, and restricted stock from her company. Stoffer believes she currently has a sufficient level of wealth to achieve her primary goal of maintaining her current lifestyle until her death.

In discussing her investment philosophy, Stoffer explains that she likes to keep separate investment accounts for her savings, stock options, and restricted stock. She has a distinct investment strategy for each account. In addition, Stoffer says that she always follows her father’s investment advice of “invest only in what you know.” Stoffer also believes that she is personally contributing to the performance of her bank’s stock price. Combined, these factors have led Stoffer to keep a large percentage of her total portfolio in her bank’s stock and options. The advisor tells Stoffer that this concentrated holding represents significant risk in achieving her primary goal. Stoffer refuses to consider the suggestion that she partially hedge the risk of her bank’s stock.

After evaluating Stoffer’s investment philosophy, the advisor is concerned that Stoffer is exhibiting some of the following cognitive biases:

  • endowment
  • conservatism
  • mental accounting
  • illusion of control
Identify two cognitive biases exhibited by Stoffer. Justify each response with one reason.


选项:

解释:


Endowment bias is an emotional bias in which people value an asset more when they hold the rights to it than when they do not. There is no evidence that Stoffer suffers from this bias. In addition, this is not a cognitive bias.

Conservatism bias is a belief perseverance bias in which people maintain their prior views or

forecasts by inadequately incorporating new information. There is no evidence that Stoffer suffers from this cognitive bias.

以下是我的答案,老师帮忙看下会否过于复杂?因为之前看其他题的时候有说写作题需要写 结论+结果/原因+解释


illusion of control:

the investor believes they can affect the result of the company's performance, and hold more stock than reasonable, which could result in under diversified portfolio, and take more risks. Stoffer also believes that she is personally contributing to the performance of her bank’s stock price.

 

mental accounting: 

the investors would arrange their investment based on the source of income, and this would bring under diversification to the portfolio. She has a distinct investment strategy for each account.

1 个答案

王琛_品职助教 · 2023年07月17日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


1)这道题答案只需要陈述现象吗?

从题目的问法来看 "Justify each response with one reason."

侧重于咱们介绍的答题框架 "结论+证据+解释" 当中的「证据」

「结论」,对应这道题,就是勾选出正确的行为偏差

「解释」,一般是写行为偏差的定义或者结果

2)以下是我的答案,老师帮忙看下会否过于复杂?因为之前看其他题的时候有说写作题需要写 结论+结果/原因+解释

不复杂

同学的答案,相当于增加了行为偏差的定义或结果,是更加完整的参考答案哈

考试时建议还是参考咱们的答题框架更妥善一些哈

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 197

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023012803000001 问题如下 their initimeeting, the aisor learns thStoffer is a milevel manager a bank anhbuilt investment portfolio accumulating savings, stooptions, anrestrictestofrom her company. Stoffer believes she currently ha sufficient level of wealth to achieve her primary goof maintaining her current lifestyle until her ath. In scussing her investment philosophy, Stoffer explains thshe likes to keep separate investment accounts for her savings, stooptions, anrestrictestock. She ha stininvestment strategy for eaaccount. In aition, Stoffer says thshe always follows her father’s investment aiof “invest only in whyou know.” Stoffer also believes thshe is personally contributing to the performanof her bank’s stoprice. Combine these factors have leStoffer to keep a large percentage of her totportfolio in her bank’s stoanoptions. The aisor tells Stoffer ththis concentrateholng represents significant risk in achieving her primary goal. Stoffer refuses to consir the suggestion thshe partially hee the risk of her bank’s stock. After evaluating Stoffer’s investment philosophy, the aisor is concernethStoffer is exhibiting some of the following cognitive biases: enwment conservatism mentaccounting illusion of control Intify two cognitive biases exhibiteStoffer. Justify earesponse with one reason. Enwment biis emotionbiin whipeople value asset more when they holthe rights to it thwhen they not. There is no evinthStoffer suffers from this bias. In aition, this is not a cognitive bias.Conservatism biis a belief perseveranbiin whipeople maintain their prior views or forecasts inaquately incorporating new information. There is no evinthStoffer suffers from this cognitive bias. 如果题目不限制cognitive errors, 是不是这里也体现了enwment bias?看描述感觉和enwment bias也很相符,而且下面中也有enwment bias。是不是因为题中说是cognitive error所以才不能回答enwment bias呢?如果没有这个限制,是不是enwment bias也是对的?

2023-06-07 21:40 1 · 回答