开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

chbe · 2023年05月02日

老师好,我不理解的是为什么跌破min asset level移除业绩计算是成立的?

NO.PZ2022010601000011

问题如下:

GTA is an investment management company. They set a minimum asset level of 50 million euros for a composite of mid-cap stocks. When GTA's investment manager Johnson managed this portfolio, due to market volatility caused by the Fed's interest rate hike, the value of this mid-cap stock portfolio below the composite-specific minimum asset level for 3 months. At this time, considering that it is the prime time for value investment, the client made additional contributions and his assets regained more than 50 million euros. Within 3 months of the investment portfolio being below the composite minimum asset level, Johnson must:

选项:

A.

temporarily switch the Johnson portfolio to the firm’s miscellaneous composite.

B.

include the Johnson portfolio in the mid-cap stocks composite in all measurement periods.

C.

exclude the Johnson portfolio from the mid-cap stocks composite for the period it was below the minimum asset level.

解释:

C is correct.

GIPS 标准规定,“如果公司为要包含在 composite中的投资组合设定了最低资产水平,则公司不得在该 composite中包含低于最低资产水平的投资组合。”但是,公司可以设定一个最低资产水平的添加值,在该水平上将投资组合添加到composite中,然后设置另一个不同于添加值的移除值,投资组合必须从 composite中移除(打个比方,移入的最小资产水平是500万,移除的资产水平是400万)。除非Johnson的政策为从composite中添加和删除投资组合指定不同的最低资产水平,否则当投资组合的资产低于最低值时,Johnson必须将这个已经低于最低资产值的中盘股投资组合从这个composite中移除,并在再次符合条件时将其返回到 composite中。 A 不正确,因为必须根据类似的投资指令、目标和/或策略来定义组合;不应有“杂项”组合。

3.A.11 If the firm sets a minimum asset level for portfolios to be included in a composite, the firm:

Must not include portfolios below the composite-specific minimum asset level in that composite.

Must not apply retroactively any changes to that composite-specific minimum asset level.

老师好,我不理解的是为什么跌破min asset level移除业绩计算是成立的。这样操作,composite的计算岂不是可以在一定程度上排除了一些样本数量和极端样本值?如果asset level刚好是本金值,那低于本金的都可以移除,怎么公允反应经理管理composite的水平?跌破后大资产还有得救,小资产直接放弃了?

1 个答案

伯恩_品职助教 · 2023年05月04日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


首先,这个GIPS不要纠结,这个就像法律条文,规矩是人家定的,所以必须按照人家的执行。

然后我试着解释一下,你看有没有道理,通常portfolios有一定的容量的,只有高于这个值才有参考意义。比如设置100万是一个临界值,小于这个很多策略都可以发挥,可能操作的都还很好,但是一旦高过这个值,很多策略就做不了,比如高频买入卖出会比较麻烦。导致100万以上的普遍做的不如100万以下的。但是一个正常的portfolio募集的资金都是高于这个值,用小的资产水平的组合给客户作参考不合适,容易误导。

----------------------------------------------
虽然现在很辛苦,但努力过的感觉真的很好,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 367

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2022010601000011问题如下 GTA is investment management company. They set a minimum asset level of 50 million euros for a composite of micstocks. When GTA's investment manager Johnson managethis portfolio, e to market volatility causethe Fes interest rate hike, the value of this micstoportfolio below the composite-specific minimum asset level for 3 months. this time, consiring thit is the prime time for value investment, the client ma aitioncontributions anhis assets regainemore th50 million euros. Within 3 months of the investment portfolio being below the composite minimum asset level, Johnson must: A.temporarily switthe Johnson portfolio to the firm’s miscellaneous composite.B.inclu the Johnson portfolio in the micstocks composite in all measurement perio.C.exclu the Johnson portfolio from the micstocks composite for the perioit wbelow the minimum asset level. C is correct. GIPS 标准规定,“如果公司为要包含在 composite中的投资组合设定了最低资产水平,则公司不得在该 composite中包含低于最低资产水平的投资组合。”但是,公司可以设定一个最低资产水平的添加值,在该水平上将投资组合添加到composite中,然后设置另一个不同于添加值的移除值,投资组合必须从 composite中移除(打个比方,移入的最小资产水平是500万,移除的资产水平是400万)。除非Johnson的政策为从composite中添加和删除投资组合指定不同的最低资产水平,否则当投资组合的资产低于最低值时,Johnson必须将这个已经低于最低资产值的中盘股投资组合从这个composite中移除,并在再次符合条件时将其返回到 composite中。 A 不正确,因为必须根据类似的投资指令、目标和/或策略来定义组合;不应有“杂项”组合。3.A.11 If the firm sets a minimum asset level for portfolios to incluin a composite, the firm:Must not inclu portfolios below the composite-specific minimum asset level in thcomposite.Must not apply retroactively any changes to thcomposite-specific minimum asset level. 所以A的micellenous composite这个词就是瞎编出来的,实际不能有这个东西?

2024-04-03 14:15 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022010601000011 问题如下 GTA is investment management company. They set a minimum asset level of 50 million euros for a composite of micstocks. When GTA's investment manager Johnson managethis portfolio, e to market volatility causethe Fes interest rate hike, the value of this micstoportfolio below the composite-specific minimum asset level for 3 months. this time, consiring thit is the prime time for value investment, the client ma aitioncontributions anhis assets regainemore th50 million euros. Within 3 months of the investment portfolio being below the composite minimum asset level, Johnson must: A.temporarily switthe Johnson portfolio to the firm’s miscellaneous composite. B.inclu the Johnson portfolio in the micstocks composite in all measurement perio. C.exclu the Johnson portfolio from the micstocks composite for the perioit wbelow the minimum asset level. C is correct. GIPS 标准规定,“如果公司为要包含在 composite中的投资组合设定了最低资产水平,则公司不得在该 composite中包含低于最低资产水平的投资组合。”但是,公司可以设定一个最低资产水平的添加值,在该水平上将投资组合添加到composite中,然后设置另一个不同于添加值的移除值,投资组合必须从 composite中移除(打个比方,移入的最小资产水平是500万,移除的资产水平是400万)。除非Johnson的政策为从composite中添加和删除投资组合指定不同的最低资产水平,否则当投资组合的资产低于最低值时,Johnson必须将这个已经低于最低资产值的中盘股投资组合从这个composite中移除,并在再次符合条件时将其返回到 composite中。 A 不正确,因为必须根据类似的投资指令、目标和/或策略来定义组合;不应有“杂项”组合。3.A.11 If the firm sets a minimum asset level for portfolios to incluin a composite, the firm:Must not inclu portfolios below the composite-specific minimum asset level in thcomposite.Must not apply retroactively any changes to thcomposite-specific minimum asset level. miscellaneous composite是一个什么概念?这个是原版书介绍过的么?

2024-02-03 18:29 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022010601000011问题如下 GTA is investment management company. They set a minimum asset level of 50 million euros for a composite of micstocks. When GTA's investment manager Johnson managethis portfolio, e to market volatility causethe Fes interest rate hike, the value of this micstoportfolio below the composite-specific minimum asset level for 3 months. this time, consiring thit is the prime time for value investment, the client ma aitioncontributions anhis assets regainemore th50 million euros. Within 3 months of the investment portfolio being below the composite minimum asset level, Johnson must: A.temporarily switthe Johnson portfolio to the firm’s miscellaneous composite.B.inclu the Johnson portfolio in the micstocks composite in all measurement perio.C.exclu the Johnson portfolio from the micstocks composite for the perioit wbelow the minimum asset level. C is correct. GIPS 标准规定,“如果公司为要包含在 composite中的投资组合设定了最低资产水平,则公司不得在该 composite中包含低于最低资产水平的投资组合。”但是,公司可以设定一个最低资产水平的添加值,在该水平上将投资组合添加到composite中,然后设置另一个不同于添加值的移除值,投资组合必须从 composite中移除(打个比方,移入的最小资产水平是500万,移除的资产水平是400万)。除非Johnson的政策为从composite中添加和删除投资组合指定不同的最低资产水平,否则当投资组合的资产低于最低值时,Johnson必须将这个已经低于最低资产值的中盘股投资组合从这个composite中移除,并在再次符合条件时将其返回到 composite中。 A 不正确,因为必须根据类似的投资指令、目标和/或策略来定义组合;不应有“杂项”组合。3.A.11 If the firm sets a minimum asset level for portfolios to incluin a composite, the firm:Must not inclu portfolios below the composite-specific minimum asset level in thcomposite.Must not apply retroactively any changes to thcomposite-specific minimum asset level. 根据题目所述,客户后面补充了资金 以达到最低的资产要求,为何还是要移出呢?

2023-06-18 08:47 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2022010601000011问题如下 GTA is investment management company. They set a minimum asset level of 50 million euros for a composite of micstocks. When GTA's investment manager Johnson managethis portfolio, e to market volatility causethe Fes interest rate hike, the value of this micstoportfolio below the composite-specific minimum asset level for 3 months. this time, consiring thit is the prime time for value investment, the client ma aitioncontributions anhis assets regainemore th50 million euros. Within 3 months of the investment portfolio being below the composite minimum asset level, Johnson must: A.temporarily switthe Johnson portfolio to the firm’s miscellaneous composite.B.inclu the Johnson portfolio in the micstocks composite in all measurement perio.C.exclu the Johnson portfolio from the micstocks composite for the perioit wbelow the minimum asset level. C is correct. GIPS 标准规定,“如果公司为要包含在 composite中的投资组合设定了最低资产水平,则公司不得在该 composite中包含低于最低资产水平的投资组合。”但是,公司可以设定一个最低资产水平的添加值,在该水平上将投资组合添加到composite中,然后设置另一个不同于添加值的移除值,投资组合必须从 composite中移除(打个比方,移入的最小资产水平是500万,移除的资产水平是400万)。除非Johnson的政策为从composite中添加和删除投资组合指定不同的最低资产水平,否则当投资组合的资产低于最低值时,Johnson必须将这个已经低于最低资产值的中盘股投资组合从这个composite中移除,并在再次符合条件时将其返回到 composite中。 A 不正确,因为必须根据类似的投资指令、目标和/或策略来定义组合;不应有“杂项”组合。3.A.11 If the firm sets a minimum asset level for portfolios to incluin a composite, the firm:Must not inclu portfolios below the composite-specific minimum asset level in thcomposite.Must not apply retroactively any changes to thcomposite-specific minimum asset level. 暂时移除之后这个portfolio有没有可能没有包含在任何composite中,那规定“所有满足scretionary fee- paying和actual的SMA账户都要加入composite要怎么满足呢?另外三个月移除期间,需不需要单独写附录说明这个问题,毕竟原composite业绩计算方法不一样了

2022-05-29 00:37 1 · 回答