开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

TZXคิดถึง · 2023年04月25日

可以分析一下其他两个选项为什么错吗?

NO.PZ2023032701000081

问题如下:

Smirnoff makes the following three statements regarding different relative valuation approaches:

In assessing BTP's trailing P/E, be sure to adjust for its countercyclical property called the "Molodovsky effect."

The P/E-to-growth (PEG) measure is better than P/E because it correctly accounts for differences in risk and the duration of growth between BTP and its peers.

Note that BTP's return on equity (ROE) is much higher than its peers. Therefore, on the basis of justified P/B, BTP will appear overvalued relative to its peers with the same P/B.

Which of the three statements regarding relative valuation approaches that Smirnoff has stated is most accurate? Her statement concerning the:

选项:

A.

PEG measure

B.

P/E

C.

justified P/B

解释:

BTP is a cyclical company. Empirically, P/Es for cyclical companies are often highly volatile over a cycle even without any change in business prospects. High P/Es on depressed earnings per share (EPS) at the bottom of the cycle and low P/Es on unusually high EPS at the top of the cycle reflect the countercyclical property of P/Es known as the Molodovsky effect.

可以分析一下其他两个选项为什么错吗?

2 个答案
已采纳答案

王园圆_品职助教 · 2023年04月25日

同学你好,请看以下讲义截图

第一张对应第二个statement——题目的说法和讲义正好相反,所以是错的。因为PEG ratio是一个时点的值,也没有任何一个值和risk还有期限有关。

第二张对应statement3——justified P/B对应的是value而不是price,所以ROE越大,value就越大,那么同样的P/B下BTP公司value更高,说明越被低估而不是高估


Katherine · 2024年04月01日

第二张对应statement3——justified P/B对应的是value而不是price,所以ROE越大,value就越大,那么同样的P/B下BTP公司value更高,说明越被低估而不是高估 “那么同样的P/B下BTP公司value更高,说明越被低估而不是高估” 这句可以辛苦解释下逻辑吗,高低估的逻辑没有理解。。。

王园圆_品职助教 · 2024年04月01日

同学你好,高估低估,是指的价格相对价值是偏高了还是偏低了

P/B一样的两家公司,可以先看成是价格是相同的

此时一家公司的ROE更高,那其对应的justified P/B就越高,而justified P/B代表的是value,也就是ROE越高,value就越高

价格一样的两家公司一家value其实更高,price应该和value一致才对,现在价格明显偏低了, 不就是被低估了吗

  • 2

    回答
  • 3

    关注
  • 420

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2023032701000081问题如下 Smirnoff makes the following three statements regarng fferent relative valuation approaches:• In assessing BTP's trailing P/E, sure to aust for its countercyclicproperty callethe \"Molovsky effect.\"• The P/E-to-growth (PEG) measure is better thP/E because it correctly accounts for fferences in risk anthe ration of growth between BTP anits peers.• Note thBTP's return on equity (ROE) is muhigher thits peers. Therefore, on the basis of justifieP/BTP will appeovervaluerelative to its peers with the same P/B.Whiof the three statements regarng relative valuation approaches thSmirnoff hstateis most accurate? Her statement concerning the: A.PEG measureB.P/EC.justifieP/BTP is a cycliccompany. Empirically, P/Es for cycliccompanies are often highly volatile over a cycle even without any change in business prospects. High P/Es on presseearnings per share (EPS) the bottom of the cycle anlow P/Es on unusually high EPS the top of the cycle reflethe countercyclicproperty of P/Es known the Molovsky effect. “justifieP/B对应的是value而不是price,所以ROE越大,value就越大”,根据v0=B0+ROE-re/re-g*B0的公式可以得出这个结论。“那么同样的P/B下BTP公司value更高,说明越被低估而不是高估”怎么得出的这个结论?P/B=ROE-g/re-g,同样的P/B,那不就是同样的ROE-g/re-g,目标公司ROE更大,只能说明它的re也更大,怎么和value挂上钩的?这里又有被低估和高估什么事?

2023-09-28 16:15 2 · 回答