开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

Jwang · 2024年07月18日

如题

  1. CFA III
  2. Fixed Income

NO.PZ2018120301000020

问题如下：

After providing Trey with advice on direct investment, Serena offered him additional information on alternative indirect investment strategies using (1) bond mutual funds, (2) exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and (3) total return swaps.

Trey expresses interest in using bond mutual funds rather than the other strategies for the following reasons.

1. Reason 1: Total return swaps have much higher transaction costs and initial cash outlay than bond mutual funds.

2. Reason 2: Unlike bond mutual funds, bond ETFs can trade at discounts to their underlying indexes, and those discounts can persist.

3. Reason 3: Bond mutual funds can be traded throughout the day at the net asset value of the underlying bonds.

Which of Trey’s reasons for choosing bond mutual funds as an investment vehicle is correct?

选项：

A.

Reason 1

B.

Reason 2

C.

Reason 3

解释：

Correct Answer: B

B is correct. Although a significant spread between the market price of the underlying fixed-income securities portfolio and an ETF’s NAV should drive an authorized participant to engage in arbitrage, many fixed-income securities are either thinly traded or not traded at all. This situation might allow such a divergence to persist.

老师好，ETF的premium或discount会出现，但是会persist这个表达还是有问题吧？并不会一直持续可被套利？

添加评论
1 个答案
已采纳答案

发亮_品职助教 · 2024年07月19日

这个表达没有问题，这是原版书的原句哈（many fixed-income securities are either thinly traded or not traded at all might allow such a divergence to persist to a much greater degree for a bond ETF than might be the case in the equity market.）


债券的ETF，他的二级市场价格与内在价值NAV之间会存在价差（divergence），并且这个价差可能会持续很久。


理论上讲，存在ETF一级市场与二级市场的套利机制，如果二级市场的价格与一级市场的构建ETF价格NAV不相等的话，投资者总可以低买高卖赚取价差，这种套利行为一定会推动着一级市场的价格NAV与二级市场的ETF价格一致，最终没有divergence。


但这也是理论状态。在债券的市场上，很多债券要么是流动性差，要么是根本没有交易，所以我们很难在一级市场上买入债券组装成ETF份额（diffcult to create ETF shares），于是即便内在价值NAV与ETF二级市场价有价差，也没办法执行套利。所以这个价差可能会比较大，or价差可能会persist比较长的时间。这是套利机制的限制导致的。


相比较的话，Equity的流动性更好，这种套利机制可以比较顺畅地执行，所以Equity ETF的这种价差相对小一点，且不太会持续。

Jwang · 2024年07月19日

明白了 谢谢老师！

发亮_品职助教 · 2024年07月21日

不用客气哈

  • 1

    回答

  • 2

    关注

  • 167

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2018120301000020 问题如下 Afterproving Trey with aion reinvestment, Serena offerehim aitionalinformation on alternative inreinvestment strategies using (1) bonmutualfun, (2) exchange-trafun (ETFs), an(3) totreturn swaps. Treyexpresses interest in using bonmutufun rather ththe other strategiesfor the following reasons.1. Reason 1: Totreturn swaps have muhighertransaction costs aniniticash outlthbonmutufun. 2. Reason 2: Unlike bonmutufun, bonETFsctra scounts to their unrlying inxes, anthose scounts canpersist. 3. Reason 3: Bonmutufun ctrahroughout the y the net asset value of the unrlying bon.Whichof Trey’s reasons for choosing bonmutufun investment vehicle iscorrect? A.Reason 1 B.Reason 2 C.Reason 3 CorreAnswer: is correct. Although a significant sprebetween the market priof the unrlying fixeincome securities portfolio anETF’s Nshoulive authorizeparticipant to engage in arbitrage, many fixeincome securities are either thinly traor not traall. This situation might allow sua vergento persist. 虽然我明白，reason 1和3的表述直接是错的，但是为什么第二点能让他对mutufun兴趣呢？我觉得就算是ETF因为很难凑齐一篮子债券而导致不好套利，也不见得就一定要去投Mutufun，还可以投TRS啊，不是更好吗？

2024-04-21 20:54 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018120301000020问题如下 Afterproving Trey with aion reinvestment, Serena offerehim aitionalinformation on alternative inreinvestment strategies using (1) bonmutualfun, (2) exchange-trafun (ETFs), an(3) totreturn swaps. Treyexpresses interest in using bonmutufun rather ththe other strategiesfor the following reasons.1. Reason 1: Totreturn swaps have muhighertransaction costs aniniticash outlthbonmutufun. 2. Reason 2: Unlike bonmutufun, bonETFsctra scounts to their unrlying inxes, anthose scounts canpersist. 3. Reason 3: Bonmutufun ctrahroughout the y the net asset value of the unrlying bon.Whichof Trey’s reasons for choosing bonmutufun investment vehicle iscorrect? A.Reason 1B.Reason 2C.Reason 3 CorreAnswer: is correct. Although a significant sprebetween the market priof the unrlying fixeincome securities portfolio anETF’s Nshoulive authorizeparticipant to engage in arbitrage, many fixeincome securities are either thinly traor not traall. This situation might allow sua vergento persist. 我想请问一下，针对第一个原因，swap的成本不是会高一些吗？因为尽管是OTC产品，但是有margin要求？还有，ETF NAV和二级市场的价差会一直持续吗？可以总套利？另外，想问一下这个题的考点对应讲义哪里呢？我都不记得哪里说哪些是日间交易，哪些是什么时候交易了。谢谢

2024-03-26 08:47 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018120301000020 问题如下 Afterproving Trey with aion reinvestment, Serena offerehim aitionalinformation on alternative inreinvestment strategies using (1) bonmutualfun, (2) exchange-trafun (ETFs), an(3) totreturn swaps. Treyexpresses interest in using bonmutufun rather ththe other strategiesfor the following reasons.1. Reason 1: Totreturn swaps have muhighertransaction costs aniniticash outlthbonmutufun. 2. Reason 2: Unlike bonmutufun, bonETFsctra scounts to their unrlying inxes, anthose scounts canpersist. 3. Reason 3: Bonmutufun ctrahroughout the y the net asset value of the unrlying bon.Whichof Trey’s reasons for choosing bonmutufun investment vehicle iscorrect? A.Reason 1 B.Reason 2 C.Reason 3 CorreAnswer: is correct. Although a significant sprebetween the market priof the unrlying fixeincome securities portfolio anETF’s Nshoulive authorizeparticipant to engage in arbitrage, many fixeincome securities are either thinly traor not traall. This situation might allow sua vergento persist. C为何是错误的？

2023-07-06 17:25 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2018120301000020 问题如下 Afterproving Trey with aion reinvestment, Serena offerehim aitionalinformation on alternative inreinvestment strategies using (1) bonmutualfun, (2) exchange-trafun (ETFs), an(3) totreturn swaps. Treyexpresses interest in using bonmutufun rather ththe other strategiesfor the following reasons.1. Reason 1: Totreturn swaps have muhighertransaction costs aniniticash outlthbonmutufun. 2. Reason 2: Unlike bonmutufun, bonETFsctra scounts to their unrlying inxes, anthose scounts canpersist. 3. Reason 3: Bonmutufun ctrahroughout the y the net asset value of the unrlying bon.Whichof Trey’s reasons for choosing bonmutufun investment vehicle iscorrect? A.Reason 1 B.Reason 2 C.Reason 3 CorreAnswer: is correct. Although a significant sprebetween the market priof the unrlying fixeincome securities portfolio anETF’s Nshoulive authorizeparticipant to engage in arbitrage, many fixeincome securities are either thinly traor not traall. This situation might allow sua vergento persist. 老师可以分析一下A吗

2023-02-19 05:27 1 · 回答