开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

金融民工阿聪 · 2023年01月24日

这题对于active和passive有点疑惑

NO.PZ2016010501000005

问题如下:

Kalila Al-Khalili has been hired as a consultant to a Middle Eastern sovereign wealth fund. The fund‘s oversight committee has asked her to examine the fund‘s financial characteristics and recommend an appropriate currency management strategy given the fund's Investment Policy Statement. After a thorough study of the fund and its finances, Al-Khalili reaches the following conclusions:

The fund's mandate is focused on the long-term development of the country, and the royal family (who are very influential on the fund's oversight committee) are prepared to take a long-term perspective on the fund's investments.

The fund's strategic asset allocation is tilted towards equity rather than fixed-income assets.

Both its fixed-income and equity portfolios have a sizeable exposure to emerging market assets.

Currently, about 90% of exchange rate exposures are hedged although the IPS allows a range of hedge ratios.

Liquidity needs of the fund are minimal, since the government is running a balanced budget and is unlikely to need to dip into the fund in the near term to cover fiscal deficits. Indeed, the expected lifetime of country's large oil reserves has been greatly extended by recent discoveries, and substantial oil royalties are expected to persist into the future.

Based on her investigation, Al-Khalili would most likely recommend:

选项:

A.

active currency management.

B.

a hedging ratio closer to 100%.

C.

a narrow discretionary band for currency exposures.

解释:

A is correct.

The fund has a long-term perspective, few immediate liquidity needs, and a lower weight in fixed income that in equities (bond portfolios are typically associated with hedge ratios closer to 100% than equity portfolios). The emerging market exposure would also support active management, given these countries' typically higher yields (carry trade) and often volatile exchange rates.

B is incorrect because the characteristics of the fund and the beneficial investor (in this case, the royal family) do not argue for a conservative currency strategy.

C is incorrect because a more active currency management strategy would be more suitable for this fund.

中文解析:

题干中描述的这个这个基金的特征包括长期性,倾向于投资股票,在发展国家市场有投资,以及流动性需求小等特点,都告诉我们这只基金没有现在必须要兑付的一些流动性要求呀,或者负债偿付(如果有的话,我们可能需要把敞口尽可能的hedge住),相反的考虑到投资发展中国家市场可能会面临较高的汇率变动,我们应该做更加积极主动地管理(A选项对),而不需要100% hedge住(B选项不对),或者在外汇管理上有更少的自主管理(C选项不对)。

另外,发展中国家一般利率比较高,同时波动比较大。这样就表示投资发展中国家会有很多可能性很多的不确定性(不确定性也就是风险),因为风险与收益并存,于是我们想抓住不确定性中好的可能性来进行获利。所以我们在不断捕捉好的可能性的时候需要的是主动管理,不断根据市场变化,来采取积极主动的措施抓住机会。所以我们在外汇管理中遇到投资发展中国家的情况,默认采取active management。

这题的long-term investment说明→more fully hedged

higher proportion in equity→do not hedge(相对于bond和fx有high correlation才要more hedged)

emerging market→more fully hedged



那么判断的标准就非常模糊,也就是说其实你从这些条件出发没啥用(有些倾向于hedge,有些倾向于not hedge),那么得出的hedge or not hedge就不能决定到底是active or passive?

所以其实给一堆条件都是虚的,是得通过说市场是波动与否,太过波动就得使用active,比较平稳就passive,是这样吗?


2 个答案
已采纳答案

Hertz_品职助教 · 2023年01月26日

嗨,努力学习的PZer你好:


同学你好

同学总结的三条,有两条是不对的哈:

1. 短期投资更倾向于要fully hedge,因为短期波动大;所以本题长期性投资是倾向于不作hedge 的;

2. 同学对投资equity的分析正确,倾向于不作hedge;

3. 投资于发展中国家,不能更多的做对冲,需要主动管理。

 

因此上面这几条都说明不倾向于做对冲,投资发展中国家更是不能对冲,而是需要主动管理。

建议同学把强化班讲义的20页,有一个关于是否需要做对冲总结的那个表格再来熟悉下哈

----------------------------------------------
努力的时光都是限量版,加油!

Hertz_品职助教 · 2023年02月02日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


同学你好

20页的表格里面第六条说financial markets volatile越高→越要fully hedge,emerging market不就是波动很高的吗,为什么emerging market反而要多hedge呢,这不是矛盾了

——

不是矛盾了哈。

这里我们可以分成两部分来理解,除了emerging market以外,市场波动率大,就是风险越大嘛,所以肯定倾向于对冲;

但是如果是emerging market,注意我们是把他判断为active management。因为投资新兴市场就是想赚点钱嘛,要不然就没有必要去投资在这样不成熟、风险大的市场上了。想一下如果全部对冲了,就和在其他市场上投资没有区别了。

所以这点我们需要特殊理解和记忆下哈。

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

  • 2

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 303

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2016010501000005 问题如下 Kalila Al-Khalili hbeen hirea consultant to a Mile Eastern sovereign wealth fun The funs oversight committee haskeher to examine the funs financicharacteristianrecommenappropriate currenmanagement strategy given the funs Investment PoliStatement. After a thorough stu of the funanits finances, Al-Khalili reaches the following conclusions:■ The funs mante is focuseon the long-term velopment of the country, anthe royfamily (who are very influention the funs oversight committee) are prepareto take a long-term perspective on the funs investments.■The funs strategic asset allocation is tiltetowar equity rather thfixeincome assets.■Both its fixeincome anequity portfolios have a sizeable exposure to emerging market assets.■Currently, about 90% of exchange rate exposures are heealthough the IPS allows a range of hee ratios.■Liquity nee of the funare minimal, sinthe government is running a balancebuet anis unlikely to neeto p into the funin the neterm to cover fiscficits. Ine the expectelifetime of country's large oil reserves hbeen greatly extenrecent scoveries, ansubstantioil royalties are expecteto persist into the future.Baseon her investigation, Al-Khalili woulmost likely recommen A.active currenmanagement. B.a heing ratio closer to 100%. C.a narrow scretionary banfor currenexposures. A is correct.The funha long-term perspective, few immeate liquity nee, ana lower weight in fixeincome thin equities (bonportfolios are typically associatewith hee ratios closer to 100% thequity portfolios). The emerging market exposure woulalso support active management, given these countries' typically higher yiel (carry tra) anoften volatile exchange rates.B is incorrebecause the characteristiof the funanthe beneficiinvestor (in this case, the royfamily) not argue for a conservative currenstrategy.C is incorrebecause a more active currenmanagement strategy woulmore suitable for this fun中文解析题干中描述的这个这个基金的特征包括长期性,倾向于投资股票,在发展国家市场有投资,以及流动性需求小等特点,都告诉我们这只基金没有现在必须要兑付的一些流动性要求呀,或者负债偿付(如果有的话,我们可能需要把敞口尽可能的hee住),相反的考虑到投资发展中国家市场可能会面临较高的汇率变动,我们应该做更加积极主动地管理(A对),而不需要100% hee住(B不对),或者在外汇管理上有更少的自主管理(C不对)。另外,发展中国家一般利率比较高,同时波动比较大。这样就表示投资发展中国家会有很多可能性很多的不确定性(不确定性也就是风险),因为风险与收益并存,于是我们想抓住不确定性中好的可能性来进行获利。所以我们在不断捕捉好的可能性的时候需要的是主动管理,不断根据市场变化,来采取积极主动的措施抓住机会。所以我们在外汇管理中遇到投资发展中国家的情况,默认采取active management。 就是我知道A是对的,但是B为什么是错的。

2024-09-19 15:38 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016010501000005 问题如下 Kalila Al-Khalili hbeen hirea consultant to a Mile Eastern sovereign wealth fun The funs oversight committee haskeher to examine the funs financicharacteristianrecommenappropriate currenmanagement strategy given the funs Investment PoliStatement. After a thorough stu of the funanits finances, Al-Khalili reaches the following conclusions:■ The funs mante is focuseon the long-term velopment of the country, anthe royfamily (who are very influention the funs oversight committee) are prepareto take a long-term perspective on the funs investments.■The funs strategic asset allocation is tiltetowar equity rather thfixeincome assets.■Both its fixeincome anequity portfolios have a sizeable exposure to emerging market assets.■Currently, about 90% of exchange rate exposures are heealthough the IPS allows a range of hee ratios.■Liquity nee of the funare minimal, sinthe government is running a balancebuet anis unlikely to neeto p into the funin the neterm to cover fiscficits. Ine the expectelifetime of country's large oil reserves hbeen greatly extenrecent scoveries, ansubstantioil royalties are expecteto persist into the future.Baseon her investigation, Al-Khalili woulmost likely recommen A.active currenmanagement. B.a heing ratio closer to 100%. C.a narrow scretionary banfor currenexposures. A is correct.The funha long-term perspective, few immeate liquity nee, ana lower weight in fixeincome thin equities (bonportfolios are typically associatewith hee ratios closer to 100% thequity portfolios). The emerging market exposure woulalso support active management, given these countries' typically higher yiel (carry tra) anoften volatile exchange rates.B is incorrebecause the characteristiof the funanthe beneficiinvestor (in this case, the royfamily) not argue for a conservative currenstrategy.C is incorrebecause a more active currenmanagement strategy woulmore suitable for this fun中文解析题干中描述的这个这个基金的特征包括长期性,倾向于投资股票,在发展国家市场有投资,以及流动性需求小等特点,都告诉我们这只基金没有现在必须要兑付的一些流动性要求呀,或者负债偿付(如果有的话,我们可能需要把敞口尽可能的hee住),相反的考虑到投资发展中国家市场可能会面临较高的汇率变动,我们应该做更加积极主动地管理(A对),而不需要100% hee住(B不对),或者在外汇管理上有更少的自主管理(C不对)。另外,发展中国家一般利率比较高,同时波动比较大。这样就表示投资发展中国家会有很多可能性很多的不确定性(不确定性也就是风险),因为风险与收益并存,于是我们想抓住不确定性中好的可能性来进行获利。所以我们在不断捕捉好的可能性的时候需要的是主动管理,不断根据市场变化,来采取积极主动的措施抓住机会。所以我们在外汇管理中遇到投资发展中国家的情况,默认采取active management。 The funs mante is focuseon the long-term velopment of the country, anthe royfamily (who are very influention the funs oversight committee) are prepareto take a long-term perspective on the funs investments.但题目也说长期目标是保值和支持国家royfamily等等,感觉是 以长期稳定收入安全性保障为主要目标?

2024-07-31 00:10 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016010501000005 问题如下 Kalila Al-Khalili hbeen hirea consultant to a Mile Eastern sovereign wealth fun The funs oversight committee haskeher to examine the funs financicharacteristianrecommenappropriate currenmanagement strategy given the funs Investment PoliStatement. After a thorough stu of the funanits finances, Al-Khalili reaches the following conclusions:■ The funs mante is focuseon the long-term velopment of the country, anthe royfamily (who are very influention the funs oversight committee) are prepareto take a long-term perspective on the funs investments.■The funs strategic asset allocation is tiltetowar equity rather thfixeincome assets.■Both its fixeincome anequity portfolios have a sizeable exposure to emerging market assets.■Currently, about 90% of exchange rate exposures are heealthough the IPS allows a range of hee ratios.■Liquity nee of the funare minimal, sinthe government is running a balancebuet anis unlikely to neeto p into the funin the neterm to cover fiscficits. Ine the expectelifetime of country's large oil reserves hbeen greatly extenrecent scoveries, ansubstantioil royalties are expecteto persist into the future.Baseon her investigation, Al-Khalili woulmost likely recommen A.active currenmanagement. B.a heing ratio closer to 100%. C.a narrow scretionary banfor currenexposures. A is correct.The funha long-term perspective, few immeate liquity nee, ana lower weight in fixeincome thin equities (bonportfolios are typically associatewith hee ratios closer to 100% thequity portfolios). The emerging market exposure woulalso support active management, given these countries' typically higher yiel (carry tra) anoften volatile exchange rates.B is incorrebecause the characteristiof the funanthe beneficiinvestor (in this case, the royfamily) not argue for a conservative currenstrategy.C is incorrebecause a more active currenmanagement strategy woulmore suitable for this fun中文解析题干中描述的这个这个基金的特征包括长期性,倾向于投资股票,在发展国家市场有投资,以及流动性需求小等特点,都告诉我们这只基金没有现在必须要兑付的一些流动性要求呀,或者负债偿付(如果有的话,我们可能需要把敞口尽可能的hee住),相反的考虑到投资发展中国家市场可能会面临较高的汇率变动,我们应该做更加积极主动地管理(A对),而不需要100% hee住(B不对),或者在外汇管理上有更少的自主管理(C不对)。另外,发展中国家一般利率比较高,同时波动比较大。这样就表示投资发展中国家会有很多可能性很多的不确定性(不确定性也就是风险),因为风险与收益并存,于是我们想抓住不确定性中好的可能性来进行获利。所以我们在不断捕捉好的可能性的时候需要的是主动管理,不断根据市场变化,来采取积极主动的措施抓住机会。所以我们在外汇管理中遇到投资发展中国家的情况,默认采取active management。 请教老师,这题选A完全是因为新兴市场的股票和债券收益可能更高吗?如果从汇率的角度看,长期情况下是有mereverting的特点的,是不需要active management的。是否还有别的原因?另外,也请老师一下为什么不选C?

2024-07-04 20:24 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016010501000005 问题如下 Kalila Al-Khalili hbeen hirea consultant to a Mile Eastern sovereign wealth fun The funs oversight committee haskeher to examine the funs financicharacteristianrecommenappropriate currenmanagement strategy given the funs Investment PoliStatement. After a thorough stu of the funanits finances, Al-Khalili reaches the following conclusions:■ The funs mante is focuseon the long-term velopment of the country, anthe royfamily (who are very influention the funs oversight committee) are prepareto take a long-term perspective on the funs investments.■The funs strategic asset allocation is tiltetowar equity rather thfixeincome assets.■Both its fixeincome anequity portfolios have a sizeable exposure to emerging market assets.■Currently, about 90% of exchange rate exposures are heealthough the IPS allows a range of hee ratios.■Liquity nee of the funare minimal, sinthe government is running a balancebuet anis unlikely to neeto p into the funin the neterm to cover fiscficits. Ine the expectelifetime of country's large oil reserves hbeen greatly extenrecent scoveries, ansubstantioil royalties are expecteto persist into the future.Baseon her investigation, Al-Khalili woulmost likely recommen A.active currenmanagement. B.a heing ratio closer to 100%. C.a narrow scretionary banfor currenexposures. A is correct.The funha long-term perspective, few immeate liquity nee, ana lower weight in fixeincome thin equities (bonportfolios are typically associatewith hee ratios closer to 100% thequity portfolios). The emerging market exposure woulalso support active management, given these countries' typically higher yiel (carry tra) anoften volatile exchange rates.B is incorrebecause the characteristiof the funanthe beneficiinvestor (in this case, the royfamily) not argue for a conservative currenstrategy.C is incorrebecause a more active currenmanagement strategy woulmore suitable for this fun中文解析题干中描述的这个这个基金的特征包括长期性,倾向于投资股票,在发展国家市场有投资,以及流动性需求小等特点,都告诉我们这只基金没有现在必须要兑付的一些流动性要求呀,或者负债偿付(如果有的话,我们可能需要把敞口尽可能的hee住),相反的考虑到投资发展中国家市场可能会面临较高的汇率变动,我们应该做更加积极主动地管理(A对),而不需要100% hee住(B不对),或者在外汇管理上有更少的自主管理(C不对)。另外,发展中国家一般利率比较高,同时波动比较大。这样就表示投资发展中国家会有很多可能性很多的不确定性(不确定性也就是风险),因为风险与收益并存,于是我们想抓住不确定性中好的可能性来进行获利。所以我们在不断捕捉好的可能性的时候需要的是主动管理,不断根据市场变化,来采取积极主动的措施抓住机会。所以我们在外汇管理中遇到投资发展中国家的情况,默认采取active management。 这道题是active management的原因是不是就单纯是因为是emerging markets, 跟别的characteristics无关?比如\"sinthe government is running a balancebuet anis unlikely to neeto p into the funin the neterm to cover fiscficits.\",即使说了unlikely neeto p?

2024-04-16 10:08 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2016010501000005 问题如下 Kalila Al-Khalili hbeen hirea consultant to a Mile Eastern sovereign wealth fun The funs oversight committee haskeher to examine the funs financicharacteristianrecommenappropriate currenmanagement strategy given the funs Investment PoliStatement. After a thorough stu of the funanits finances, Al-Khalili reaches the following conclusions:■ The funs mante is focuseon the long-term velopment of the country, anthe royfamily (who are very influention the funs oversight committee) are prepareto take a long-term perspective on the funs investments.■The funs strategic asset allocation is tiltetowar equity rather thfixeincome assets.■Both its fixeincome anequity portfolios have a sizeable exposure to emerging market assets.■Currently, about 90% of exchange rate exposures are heealthough the IPS allows a range of hee ratios.■Liquity nee of the funare minimal, sinthe government is running a balancebuet anis unlikely to neeto p into the funin the neterm to cover fiscficits. Ine the expectelifetime of country's large oil reserves hbeen greatly extenrecent scoveries, ansubstantioil royalties are expecteto persist into the future.Baseon her investigation, Al-Khalili woulmost likely recommen A.active currenmanagement. B.a heing ratio closer to 100%. C.a narrow scretionary banfor currenexposures. A is correct.The funha long-term perspective, few immeate liquity nee, ana lower weight in fixeincome thin equities (bonportfolios are typically associatewith hee ratios closer to 100% thequity portfolios). The emerging market exposure woulalso support active management, given these countries' typically higher yiel (carry tra) anoften volatile exchange rates.B is incorrebecause the characteristiof the funanthe beneficiinvestor (in this case, the royfamily) not argue for a conservative currenstrategy.C is incorrebecause a more active currenmanagement strategy woulmore suitable for this fun中文解析题干中描述的这个这个基金的特征包括长期性,倾向于投资股票,在发展国家市场有投资,以及流动性需求小等特点,都告诉我们这只基金没有现在必须要兑付的一些流动性要求呀,或者负债偿付(如果有的话,我们可能需要把敞口尽可能的hee住),相反的考虑到投资发展中国家市场可能会面临较高的汇率变动,我们应该做更加积极主动地管理(A对),而不需要100% hee住(B不对),或者在外汇管理上有更少的自主管理(C不对)。另外,发展中国家一般利率比较高,同时波动比较大。这样就表示投资发展中国家会有很多可能性很多的不确定性(不确定性也就是风险),因为风险与收益并存,于是我们想抓住不确定性中好的可能性来进行获利。所以我们在不断捕捉好的可能性的时候需要的是主动管理,不断根据市场变化,来采取积极主动的措施抓住机会。所以我们在外汇管理中遇到投资发展中国家的情况,默认采取active management。 老师好,我可能有个知识点搞混淆了,想确认下。hee比例越高,是代表越倾向于passive是吗?我看了下大家的问题和回答,是这么理解的题目中的背景,其实暗示了可以选择更激进更active的策略,所以原先90%的hee ratio显得太高了、需要调低,是这么理解是吗?

2024-01-29 18:10 1 · 回答