开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

Nan🌞 · 2021年11月03日

这道题是不是出错了?

NO.PZ2016010801000016

问题如下:

When there is a decrease in the price of good X, and the consumption of good X also decreases, which of the following statements about the substitution effect and the income effect is most accurate?

选项:

A.

Both the substitution effect and the income effect are positive.

B.

Both the substitution effect and the income effect are negative.

C.

The substitution effect is positive and the income effect is negative.

解释:

C is correct.

If X’s price is decreasing, the substitution effect will lead a consumer to consume more of X and consume less substitution of X, which remains the previous price. The substitution effect is positive. In this question, consumption of X is decreasing as well, therefore, income effect has to be negative and larger than substitution effect.

考点:替代效应和收入效应。

解析:无论什么商品,它的替代效应总是正的,所以A选项不正确。

但是X的价格下降后,需求量出现下降,可见,其收入效应表现为负效应,所以B选项错误。C选项正确。

应该是问最不正确的,答案B。因为替代效应永远是正的,

不太明白A选项为什么错,因为当衡量normal good时,替代效应和收入效应不是都为正吗?

2 个答案

笛子_品职助教 · 2021年11月06日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


题目中自然不会说了,收入效应使负,是推理出来的。

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

笛子_品职助教 · 2021年11月03日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


首先要知道正负号的含义。

只要需求上升,就是正的,只要需求下降,就是负的。默认在价格下降的情况下。


这个题目明确了,价格下降,需求下降,也就是说,总效应是负的。


而总效应,等于,替代效应,加收入效应。替代效应永远为正,那么只能是收入效应为负。


所以A选项说,替代效应和收入效应都是正,是不对的。


不太明白A选项为什么错,因为当衡量normal good时,替代效应和收入效应不是都为正吗?

至于这个商品是不是normal good,题目没说。因为收入效应是负的,题目中的商品,并非normal good,它可能是奢侈品或者吉芬品。


知识点可参考基础班相应章节何老师的板书

----------------------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!

Nan🌞 · 2021年11月05日

多谢讲解!我理解了商品不一定是normalgood,但还是有这种可能。而且题目中没有说收入效应是负的呀?

  • 2

    回答
  • 0

    关注
  • 433

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2016010801000016 问题如下 When there is a crease in the priof gooX, anthe consumption of gooX also creases, whiof the following statements about the substitution effeanthe income effeis most accurate? A.Both the substitution effeanthe income effeare positive. B.Both the substitution effeanthe income effeare negative. C.The substitution effeis positive anthe income effeis negative. C is correct.If X’s priis creasing, the substitution effewill lea consumer to consume more of X anconsume less substitution of X, whiremains the previous price. The substitution effeis positive. In this question, consumption of X is creasing well, therefore, income effehto negative anlarger thsubstitution effect. 考点替代效应和收入效应。解析无论什么商品,它的替代效应总是正的,所以A不正确。但是X的价格下降后,需求量出现下降,可见,其收入效应表现为负效应,所以B错误。C正确。 解析中“无论什么商品,它的替代效应总是正的”。以吉芬商品为例,收入效应是负的,而且替代效应小于收入效应,为什么说所有商品的替代效应总是正的?

2023-04-18 19:54 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016010801000016 问题如下 When there is a crease in the priof gooX, anthe consumption of gooX also creases, whiof the following statements about the substitution effeanthe income effeis most accurate? A.Both the substitution effeanthe income effeare positive. B.Both the substitution effeanthe income effeare negative. C.The substitution effeis positive anthe income effeis negative. C is correct.If X’s priis creasing, the substitution effewill lea consumer to consume more of X anconsume less substitution of X, whiremains the previous price. The substitution effeis positive. In this question, consumption of X is creasing well, therefore, income effehto negative anlarger thsubstitution effect. 考点替代效应和收入效应。解析无论什么商品,它的替代效应总是正的,所以A不正确。但是X的价格下降后,需求量出现下降,可见,其收入效应表现为负效应,所以B错误。C正确。 为什么替代效应总是正的?

2022-07-12 20:37 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016010801000016 Both the substitution effeanthe income effeare negative. The substitution effeis positive anthe income effeis negative. C is correct. If X’s priis creasing, the substitution effewill lea consumer to consume more of X anconsume less substitution of X, whiremains the previous price. The substitution effeis positive. In this question, consumption of X is creasing well, therefore, income effehto negative anlarger thsubstitution effect. 考点替代效应和收入效应。 解析无论什么商品,它的替代效应总是正的,所以A不正确。 但是X的价格下降后,需求量出现下降,可见,其收入效应表现为负效应,所以B错误。C正确。 收入效应不是和是normal还是inferior有关吗,这题怎么判断是normal还是inferior呢

2022-02-16 09:02 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016010801000016 No.PZ2016010801000016 (选择题) 来源: 品职出题 When there is a crease in the priof gooX, anthe consumption of gooX also creases, whiof the following statements about the substitution effeanthe income effeis most accurate? 您的回答, 正确答案是: A Both the substitution effeanthe income effeare positive. B 不正确Both the substitution effeanthe income effeare negative. C The substitution effeis positive anthe income effeis negative. 对于这个nagetive,我认为是the priof X 和 consumption of X是正相关才对吧,那为什么答案说是positive呢

2022-02-04 16:16 1 · 回答