开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)｜3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

返回

金融民工阿聪 · 2021年03月30日

这里说针对少数据的新兴市场用HS更好

  1. FRM II
  2. Market Risk Measurement And Management

NO.PZ2016070202000013

问题如下：

The historical simulation (HS) approach is based on the empirical distributions and a large number of risk factors. The RiskMetrics approach assumes normal distributions and uses mapping on equity indices. The HS approach is more likely to provide an accurate estimate of VAR than the RiskMetrics approach for a portfolio that consists of

选项：

A.

A small number of emerging market securities

B.

A small number of broad market indices

C.

A large number of emerging market securities

D.

A large number of broad market indices

解释：

The question deals with the distribution of the assets and the effect of diversification. Emerging market securities are more volatile and less likely to be normally distributed than broad market indices. In addition, a small portfolio is less likely to be well represented by a mapping approach, and is less likely to be normal. The RiskMetrics approach assumes that the conditional distribution is normal and simplifies risk by mapping. This will be acceptable with a large number of securities with distributions close to the normal, which is answer D Answer A describes the least diversified portfolio, for which the HS method is best.

这里说针对少数据的新兴市场用HS更好，但是不是也说过，就是由于新兴市场数据不够多，HS无法捕捉到足够多的数据，所以会缺失tail loss，而通过假设正态分布来应用在缺少样本量的新兴市场的话，可以获取到更多的尾部数据，所以用正态分布的假设会更好不是吗？

添加评论
1 个答案
已采纳答案

袁园_品职助教 · 2021年03月30日

同学你好！

这题考查的是HS和RiskMetrics的比较优势。

核心是RiskMetrics的假设是正态分布，在新兴市场中容易出现极端事件，是不太符合正态分布的，所以HS有比较优势。而数据量越大越趋近于正态分布，此时HS就没有了比较优势。这题不是单纯看哪个条件对HS更好，而是哪个条件使得HS相对RiskMetrics更好。

  • 1

    回答

  • 4

    关注

  • 589

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2016070202000013问题如下 The historicsimulation (HS) approais baseon the empiricstributions ana large number of risk factors. The RiskMetriapproaassumes normstributions anuses mapping on equity inces. The HS approais more likely to provi accurate estimate of Vththe RiskMetriapproafor a portfolio thconsists ofA.A small number of emerging market securitiesB.A small number of bromarket incesC.A large number of emerging market securitiesA large number of bromarket incesThe question als with the stribution of the assets anthe effeof versification. Emerging market securities are more volatile anless likely to normally stributethbromarket inces. In aition, a small portfolio is less likely to well representea mapping approach, anis less likely to normal. The RiskMetriapproaassumes ththe contionstribution is normansimplifies risk mapping. This will acceptable with a large number of securities with stributions close to the normal, whiis answer Answer A scribes the least versifieportfolio, for whithe HS methois best.riskmetrics在讲义哪里讲到？

2023-04-11 11:15 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016070202000013问题如下The historicsimulation (HS) approais baseon the empiricstributions ana large number of risk factors. The RiskMetriapproaassumes normstributions anuses mapping on equity inces. The HS approais more likely to provi accurate estimate of Vththe RiskMetriapproafor a portfolio thconsists ofA.A small number of emerging market securitiesB.A small number of bromarket incesC.A large number of emerging market securitiesA large number of bromarket incesThe question als with the stribution of the assets anthe effeof versification. Emerging market securities are more volatile anless likely to normally stributethbromarket inces. In aition, a small portfolio is less likely to well representea mapping approach, anis less likely to normal. The RiskMetriapproaassumes ththe contionstribution is normansimplifies risk mapping. This will acceptable with a large number of securities with stributions close to the normal, whiis answer Answer A scribes the least versifieportfolio, for whithe HS methois best.讲义中说 why mapping? 1 计算量大 2特征随着时间改变 3数据太少时那就意味着 当数据少时 适合mapping， 那这个题不就是数据多时用HS更好嘛

2023-01-20 09:14 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016070202000013 问题如下 The historicsimulation (HS) approais baseon the empiricstributions ana large number of risk factors. The RiskMetriapproaassumes normstributions anuses mapping on equity inces. The HS approais more likely to provi accurate estimate of Vththe RiskMetriapproafor a portfolio thconsists of A.A small number of emerging market securities B.A small number of bromarket inces C.A large number of emerging market securities A large number of bromarket inces The question als with the stribution of the assets anthe effeof versification. Emerging market securities are more volatile anless likely to normally stributethbromarket inces. In aition, a small portfolio is less likely to well representea mapping approach, anis less likely to normal. The RiskMetriapproaassumes ththe contionstribution is normansimplifies risk mapping. This will acceptable with a large number of securities with stributions close to the normal, whiis answer Answer A scribes the least versifieportfolio, for whithe HS methois best. 老师请问riskmetrics是什么模型？这题怎么理解？包含了大量新兴市场的数据，波动性更大的异常数据多了算的不是更精确吗？

2022-11-03 15:20 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2016070202000013 这个题是不是超纲了呀，没看到知识点，然后想问一下HS的方法如果small的数据是不是也不好呀，答这道题的时候很困惑呀，不知道从哪里入手

2022-03-03 21:50 1 · 回答