开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

Xixitimesone · 2020年11月13日

问一道题:NO.PZ201809170400000804 第4小题 [ CFA III ]

* 问题详情,请 查看题干

问题如下:

Which investment approach is the mostlikely basis for Sardar’s buy recommendation for AZ Industrial?

选项:

A.

Relative value

B.

High-quality value

C.

Deep-value investing

解释:

B is correct. Dewey has developed a fundamental active investment process for the Purity Fund that emphasizesfinancial strength and demonstrated profitability. High-quality value investorsfocus on companies’ intrinsic values that are supported by attractive valuation metrics, with an emphasis on financial strength and demonstrated profitability. In their view, investors sometimes behave irrationally, making stocks trade at prices very different from intrinsic value based on company fundamentals. A is incorrect because investors who pursue a relative value strategy evaluate companies by comparing their value indicators (e.g., P/E or P/B multiples) with the average valuation of companies in the same industry sector, in an effort to identify stocks that offer value relative to their sector peers. AZ Industrial is trading at a high P/B relative to the industry average, which is contrary to relative value and suggests that the relative value approach was not the basis for Sardar’s buy recommendation. C is incorrect because a deep-value investing approach focuses on undervalued companies that are available at extremely low valuation relative to their assets. Such companies are often those in financial distress, which is not reflective of financial strength or demonstrated profitability. Therefore, Sardar’s buy recommendation was not based on a deep-value investing orientation.

请问: 1. 如果第一段没有说emphasis on financial strength and demonstrated profitability 的话,那relative value strategy和 high quality都是对的吗? 2. 这家公司被undervalue,说明price小于value,那为什么会price 高于 book value呢(high PB ratio)? 3. undervalue应该被买入,high PB应该被卖出,请问该如何抉择呢? 抱歉有点想不明白,感谢回答!
1 个答案
已采纳答案

maggie_品职助教 · 2020年11月13日

嗨,从没放弃的小努力你好:


1、不是啊,relative value strategy是用在当PE\PB都低于行业平均水平时用的策略,但这道题说PB较高那么该策略不适用。要注意每种策略它的适用范围不同

2、股票被低估,说明该股票的内在价值高于其市场价格,现在卖的便宜了,所以是低估。而不是价格小于账面价值。账面价值可不等于内在价值。

3、我们在二级学了那么多的模型都是为了给股票估值,并不是只有相对估值法(看PE/PB)来判断高估低估。通常相对估值法只是绝对估值法的一个参考。而这道题说S认为当前股价是被低估了,可能是她已经通过绝对估值模型做了测算得到的结果,但是这家公司的PB是高于平均的并不影响她的买入建议。这个地方也不需要你来做抉择。


-------------------------------
就算太阳没有迎着我们而来,我们正在朝着它而去,加油!


  • 1

    回答
  • 1

    关注
  • 743

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ201809170400000804 问题如下 Whiinvestment approais the mostlikely basis for Sarr’s buy recommention for Instrial? A.Relative value B.High-quality value C.ep-value investing B is correct. wey hvelopea funmentactive investment process for the Purity Funthemphasizesfinancistrength anmonstrateprofitability. High-quality value investorsfocus on companies’ intrinsic values thare supporteattractive valuationmetrics, with emphasis on financistrength anmonstrateprofitability.In their view, investors sometimes behave irrationally, making stocks tra atprices very fferent from intrinsic value baseon company funmentals. A isincorrebecause investors who pursue a relative value strategy evaluatecompanies comparing their value incators (e.g., P/E or P/B multiples) withthe average valuation of companies in the same instry sector, in effort tointify stocks thoffer value relative to their sector peers. Instrialis trang a high P/B relative to the instry average, whiis contrary torelative value ansuggests ththe relative value approawnot the basisfor Sarr’s buy recommention. C is incorrebecause a ep-value investingapproafocuses on unrvaluecompanies thare available extremely lowvaluation relative to their assets. Sucompanies are often those in financialstress, whiis not reflective of financistrength or monstraterofitability. Therefore, Sarr’s buy recommention wnot baseon aep-value investing orientation. relative value vs high quality value有什么明显的区别吗

2024-03-23 09:54 1 · 回答

NO.PZ201809170400000804问题如下Whiinvestment approais the mostlikely basis for Sarr’s buy recommention for Instrial? A.Relative value B.High-quality value C.ep-value investing B is correct. wey hvelopea funmentactive investment process for the Purity Funthemphasizesfinancistrength anmonstrateprofitability. High-quality value investorsfocus on companies’ intrinsic values thare supporteattractive valuationmetrics, with emphasis on financistrength anmonstrateprofitability.In their view, investors sometimes behave irrationally, making stocks tra atprices very fferent from intrinsic value baseon company funmentals. A isincorrebecause investors who pursue a relative value strategy evaluatecompanies comparing their value incators (e.g., P/E or P/B multiples) withthe average valuation of companies in the same instry sector, in effort tointify stocks thoffer value relative to their sector peers. Instrialis trang a high P/B relative to the instry average, whiis contrary torelative value ansuggests ththe relative value approawnot the basisfor Sarr’s buy recommention. C is incorrebecause a ep-value investingapproafocuses on unrvaluecompanies thare available extremely lowvaluation relative to their assets. Sucompanies are often those in financialstress, whiis not reflective of financistrength or monstraterofitability. Therefore, Sarr’s buy recommention wnot baseon aep-value investing orientation. 这题的定位不应该是后面么,怎么跑前面了

2023-12-07 11:46 1 · 回答

NO.PZ201809170400000804问题如下Whiinvestment approais the mostlikely basis for Sarr’s buy recommention for Instrial? A.Relative value B.High-quality value C.ep-value investing B is correct. wey hvelopea funmentactive investment process for the Purity Funthemphasizesfinancistrength anmonstrateprofitability. High-quality value investorsfocus on companies’ intrinsic values thare supporteattractive valuationmetrics, with emphasis on financistrength anmonstrateprofitability.In their view, investors sometimes behave irrationally, making stocks tra atprices very fferent from intrinsic value baseon company funmentals. A isincorrebecause investors who pursue a relative value strategy evaluatecompanies comparing their value incators (e.g., P/E or P/B multiples) withthe average valuation of companies in the same instry sector, in effort tointify stocks thoffer value relative to their sector peers. Instrialis trang a high P/B relative to the instry average, whiis contrary torelative value ansuggests ththe relative value approawnot the basisfor Sarr’s buy recommention. C is incorrebecause a ep-value investingapproafocuses on unrvaluecompanies thare available extremely lowvaluation relative to their assets. Sucompanies are often those in financialstress, whiis not reflective of financistrength or monstraterofitability. Therefore, Sarr’s buy recommention wnot baseon aep-value investing orientation. 这道题是要从第一段找信息点才能判断吗?从本题对应的文章信息位置看,只能用排除法,选不出quality这个因子。考试的题目也需要在前文找信息吗

2023-11-15 16:53 1 · 回答

NO.PZ201809170400000804 High-quality value ep-value investing B is correct. wey hvelopea funmentactive investment process for the Purity Funthemphasizesfinancistrength anmonstrateprofitability. High-quality value investorsfocus on companies’ intrinsic values thare supporteattractive valuationmetrics, with emphasis on financistrength anmonstrateprofitability.In their view, investors sometimes behave irrationally, making stocks tra atprices very fferent from intrinsic value baseon company funmentals. A isincorrebecause investors who pursue a relative value strategy evaluatecompanies comparing their value incators (e.g., P/E or P/B multiples) withthe average valuation of companies in the same instry sector, in effort tointify stocks thoffer value relative to their sector peers. Instrialis trang a high P/B relative to the instry average, whiis contrary torelative value ansuggests ththe relative value approawnot the basisfor Sarr’s buy recommention. C is incorrebecause a ep-value investingapproafocuses on unrvaluecompanies thare available extremely lowvaluation relative to their assets. Sucompanies are often those in financialstress, whiis not reflective of financistrength or monstraterofitability. Therefore, Sarr’s buy recommention wnot baseon aep-value investing orientation. 课后答案和李老师讲的都没懂,可不可以用中文一下这道题啊,谢谢~

2022-04-02 22:44 2 · 回答

NO.PZ201809170400000804 题目定位那段,SARA选择这家公司就是她相信指标足够低,但是高于行业(那么C不选),B没有涉及到她做这个的过程,及时文章开头说了这个基金总体是根据quality来的,但是也和本题无关吧

2022-01-11 02:54 3 · 回答