开发者:上海品职教育科技有限公司 隐私政策详情

应用版本:4.2.11(IOS)|3.2.5(安卓)APP下载

12345678 · 2023年11月24日

为什么不是杰文斯悖论?

NO.PZ2022120703000017

问题如下:

An analyst argues that a rapid transition from conventional to electric cars would continue to put a strain on natural resources. This would best be explained by:

选项:

A.population growth.

B.the Jevons paradox.

C.the shift in materials used.

解释:

C is correct because one of the aspects related to a further strain on natural resources and their depletion is the result of the shift in materials used in production. "Another aspect is the shift in the resources used. For example: Clean energy technologies generally require more minerals than fossil fuel-based counterparts. An electric car uses five times as much minerals as a conventional car (...)."

A is incorrect because population growth would not be the?most likely?reason behind a strain on natural resources related to rapid transition from conventional to electric cars. Population growth, in general, is listed among the biggest causes of increased pressure on natural resources: "The rising population will put increased strain on the world’s natural resources, most notably in terms of access to food." However, the main source of a strain related to rapid transition of the industry is stemming from the change in resources used and the fact that the new technology requires more of the minerals. "Clean energy technologies generally require more minerals than fossil fuel-based counterparts. An electric car uses five times as much minerals as a conventional car (...)."

B is incorrect because the Jevons paradox is observed when "(...) relative improvements in efficiency (using fewer resources per unit of production) may be offset by increased consumption of a given product." However, switching rapidly production line from conventional to electric cars means using more resources than for fuel-based vehicles (per car produced): "An electric car uses five times as much minerals as a conventional car (...)."

为啥不是杰文斯悖论B选项

1 个答案

Tina_品职助教 · 2023年11月25日

嗨,爱思考的PZer你好:


杰文斯悖论(Jevons Paradox)描述的是一个效率提高导致资源消耗总量增加的现象,即当技术进步提高了某种资源的使用效率时,由于该资源的有效性提高和成本降低,导致对该资源的需求和消耗总量反而增加。

然而,在这个问题的情景中,分析师指出从传统汽车向电动汽车的快速转变将继续对自然资源造成压力,这主要是由于生产中使用的材料发生了变化。电动汽车需要使用比传统汽车多五倍的矿物资源。这种情况与杰文斯悖论不符,因为杰文斯悖论涉及的是效率提高,而不是生产所需资源类型的变化。电动车使用更多矿物并不是因为资源使用效率提高了,而是因为它们本质上需要更多的某些类型的资源(如锂、钴、镍等用于电池生产的矿物)。

因此,正确答案是C,因为它直接指向从传统汽车向电动汽车转型增加了对特定自然资源的需求。这不是因为提高了效率(杰文斯悖论所讨论的),而是因为电动汽车本身就需要使用更多的矿物资源。

----------------------------------------------
虽然现在很辛苦,但努力过的感觉真的很好,加油!

  • 1

    回答
  • 1

    关注
  • 540

    浏览
相关问题

NO.PZ2022120703000017 问题如下 analyst argues tha rapitransition from conventionto electric cars woulcontinue to put a strain on naturresources. This woulbest explaineby: A.population growth. B.the Jevons parax. C.the shift in materials use C is correbecause one of the aspects relateto a further strain on naturresources antheir pletion is the result of the shift in materials usein proction. \"Another aspeis the shift in the resources use For example: Cleenergy technologies generally require more minerals thfossil fuel-basecounterparts. electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\"A is incorrebecause population growth woulnot the?most likely?reason behina strain on naturresources relateto rapitransition from conventionto electric cars. Population growth, in general, is listeamong the biggest causes of increasepressure on naturresources: \"The rising population will put increasestrain on the worls naturresources, most notably in terms of access to foo\" However, the main sourof a strain relateto rapitransition of the instry is stemming from the change in resources useanthe faththe new technology requires more of the minerals. \"Cleenergy technologies generally require more minerals thfossil fuel-basecounterparts. electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\"B is incorrebecause the Jevons parax is observewhen \"(...) relative improvements in efficien(using fewer resources per unit of proction) moffset increaseconsumption of a given proct.\" However, switching rapiy proction line from conventionto electric cars means using more resources thfor fuel-basevehicles (per cproce: \"electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\" 这道题对应的知识点在讲义中哪一章节? C.the shift in materials use在讲义中哪一章节有相关论述。

2024-09-19 15:08 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022120703000017 问题如下 analyst argues tha rapitransition from conventionto electric cars woulcontinue to put a strain on naturresources. This woulbest explaineby: A.population growth. B.the Jevons parax. C.the shift in materials use C is correbecause one of the aspects relateto a further strain on naturresources antheir pletion is the result of the shift in materials usein proction. \"Another aspeis the shift in the resources use For example: Cleenergy technologies generally require more minerals thfossil fuel-basecounterparts. electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\"A is incorrebecause population growth woulnot the?most likely?reason behina strain on naturresources relateto rapitransition from conventionto electric cars. Population growth, in general, is listeamong the biggest causes of increasepressure on naturresources: \"The rising population will put increasestrain on the worls naturresources, most notably in terms of access to foo\" However, the main sourof a strain relateto rapitransition of the instry is stemming from the change in resources useanthe faththe new technology requires more of the minerals. \"Cleenergy technologies generally require more minerals thfossil fuel-basecounterparts. electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\"B is incorrebecause the Jevons parax is observewhen \"(...) relative improvements in efficien(using fewer resources per unit of proction) moffset increaseconsumption of a given proct.\" However, switching rapiy proction line from conventionto electric cars means using more resources thfor fuel-basevehicles (per cproce: \"electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\" 能否用中文再一遍题干,我选择的是吉文斯悖论

2023-12-17 16:11 1 · 回答

NO.PZ2022120703000017问题如下 analyst argues tha rapitransition from conventionto electric cars woulcontinue to put a strain on naturresources. This woulbest explaineby: A.population growth.B.the Jevons parax.C.the shift in materials use C is correbecause one of the aspects relateto a further strain on naturresources antheir pletion is the result of the shift in materials usein proction. \"Another aspeis the shift in the resources use For example: Cleenergy technologies generally require more minerals thfossil fuel-basecounterparts. electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\"A is incorrebecause population growth woulnot the?most likely?reason behina strain on naturresources relateto rapitransition from conventionto electric cars. Population growth, in general, is listeamong the biggest causes of increasepressure on naturresources: \"The rising population will put increasestrain on the worls naturresources, most notably in terms of access to foo\" However, the main sourof a strain relateto rapitransition of the instry is stemming from the change in resources useanthe faththe new technology requires more of the minerals. \"Cleenergy technologies generally require more minerals thfossil fuel-basecounterparts. electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\"B is incorrebecause the Jevons parax is observewhen \"(...) relative improvements in efficien(using fewer resources per unit of proction) moffset increaseconsumption of a given proct.\" However, switching rapiy proction line from conventionto electric cars means using more resources thfor fuel-basevehicles (per cproce: \"electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\" C的答案在讲义哪里有出现?这是定义么?

2023-11-21 18:24 2 · 回答

NO.PZ2022120703000017 问题如下 analyst argues tha rapitransition from conventionto electric cars woulcontinue to put a strain on naturresources. This woulbest explaineby: A.population growth. B.the Jevons parax. C.the shift in materials use C is correbecause one of the aspects relateto a further strain on naturresources antheir pletion is the result of the shift in materials usein proction. \"Another aspeis the shift in the resources use For example: Cleenergy technologies generally require more minerals thfossil fuel-basecounterparts. electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\"A is incorrebecause population growth woulnot the?most likely?reason behina strain on naturresources relateto rapitransition from conventionto electric cars. Population growth, in general, is listeamong the biggest causes of increasepressure on naturresources: \"The rising population will put increasestrain on the worls naturresources, most notably in terms of access to foo\" However, the main sourof a strain relateto rapitransition of the instry is stemming from the change in resources useanthe faththe new technology requires more of the minerals. \"Cleenergy technologies generally require more minerals thfossil fuel-basecounterparts. electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\"B is incorrebecause the Jevons parax is observewhen \"(...) relative improvements in efficien(using fewer resources per unit of proction) moffset increaseconsumption of a given proct.\" However, switching rapiy proction line from conventionto electric cars means using more resources thfor fuel-basevehicles (per cproce: \"electric cuses five times muminerals a conventionc(...).\" B在哪里出现过?不记得这个知识点

2023-10-19 02:12 1 · 回答